![]() |
|
|
Vol. 53, Issue 1, 77-87, January 1998
Laboratoire de Pharmacologie Moléculaire Antitumorale du Centre Oscar Lambret, Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale Unité 124, 59045 Lille, France (C.B.), Laboratoire de Chimie Macromoléculaire et Chimie Physique, Université de Liège, Liège 4000, Belgium (P.C., C.H.), Synthèse, Electrosynthèse et Etude de Systèmes à Intérêt Biologique, Université Blaise Pascal, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique UMR 6504, 63177 Aubière cedex, France (E.R.-P., M.P.) and University of Cambridge, Department of Pharmacology, Cambridge CB2 1QJ, UK (M.J.W.)
| |
Summary |
|---|
|
|
|---|
We investigated the interaction with DNA of two synthetic derivatives of the antitumor antibiotic rebeccamycin: R-3, which is a potent topoisomerase I inhibitor and contains a methoxyglucose moiety appended to the indolocarbazole chromophore, and its aglycone, R-4. Spectroscopic measurements indicate that R-3 intercalates into DNA and that its carbohydrate domain contributes significantly to reinforce the affinity for DNA. Two complementary ligation assays concur that R-3, but not its aglycone counterpart, exerts a significant effect on the curvature and/or the flexibility of DNA. The sugar moiety may be responsible for preferential binding of R-3 to circular (or bent) DNA molecules as opposed to linear DNA fragments. The sequence selectivity of binding to DNA has been studied thoroughly by footprinting with DNase I and two other nucleases. The glycosylated compound is highly selective for nucleotide sequences containing GpT (ApC) and TpG (CpA) steps. The derivative lacking the sugar moiety on the indolocarbazole chromophore binds at essentially identical sites but with considerably lower affinity, so it seems that the chromophore rather than the carbohydrate is responsible for the preferential binding to sequences surrounding GpT and TpG steps. The influence of the exocyclic substituents present on the bases at the recognition sites (i.e., the 2-amino group of guanine and the 5-methyl group of thymine) was evaluated using two series of modified DNA molecules prepared by polymerase chain reaction containing inosine and/or 2,6-diaminopurine and uridine and/or 5-methylcytosine residues. The introduction of the amino group onto purine residues or the addition of a methyl group to pyrimidine residues suffices to create new drug binding sites. Therefore, unlike most DNA-binding small molecules, the rebeccamycin analogue seems to be highly sensitive to any modification of the exocyclic substituents on the bases in both the major and minor grooves of the double helix. The footprinting profiles with the different DNA fragments bear a remarkable resemblance to those determined for nogalamycin and bisnaphthalimide compounds known to recognize their preferred GpT and TpG sites via intercalation from the major groove. The unique DNA binding characteristics of the rebeccamycin analogue correlate well with its inhibitory effects on topoisomerase I .
| |
Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The
camptothecin derivatives irinotecan (CPT-11) and topotecan recently
introduced in cancer chemotherapy are arguably the best characterized
topoisomerase I poisons (Pommier and Tanizawa, 1993
). These drugs
interfere with the breakage-rejoining reaction by stabilizing a
covalent topoisomerase I/DNA intermediate (usually referred to as
cleavable complex), which can be detected by the appearance of DNA
strand breaks on denaturation of the protein with a detergent. So far,
relatively few other drugs have been shown to promote topoisomerase
I-mediated DNA cleavage. Intoplicine, saintopins, and related
naphthacene-dione antibiotics as well as alkaloids such as bulgarein
and coralyne (Gatto et al., 1996
; Fujii et al.,
1993
, 1997
; Leteurtre et al., 1994
; Makhey et
al., 1994
; Nabiev et al., 1994
) have been identified as
inducers of the cleavable topoisomerase I/DNA complex. In the course of
a screening program, Nakano and collaborators discovered that
indolocarbazole derivatives could also promote DNA cleavage (Yamashita
et al., 1992
; Yoshinari et al., 1993
).
Subsequently, they synthesized water-soluble analogues such as compound
NB-506 (Fig. 1), which proved to be not
only a potent topoisomerase I poison but also a promising antitumor
drug showing remarkable activity against colon and lung cancer
xenografts as well as very low toxicity (Arakawa et al.
1995
; Yoshinari et al., 1995
).
|
In a recent study, we investigated the effects of a series of
indolocarbazole derivatives structurally related to the antibiotic rebeccamycin (Bush et al., 1987
), which is a cousin of
NB-506 (Fig. 1). We found that the presence of chlorine on the
indolocarbazole chromophore (as in rebeccamycin) significantly reduces
the effect on topoisomerase I, whereas the substituents on the
maleimido function and the functional group on the nonindolic moiety
can be varied without loss of activity. In addition, we showed that the
methoxyglucose residue attached to the chromophore plays a determinant
role in facilitating interaction of the drug with DNA/topoisomerase I
complexes (Bailly et al., 1997
; Rodrigues-Pereira et
al., 1996
). However, the exact mechanism of interaction between these compounds and DNA with or without topoisomerase I remains unclear
and poorly documented. To gain further insight into their binding to
DNA and possible recognition of specific nucleotide sequences, we
investigated the compound R-3 shown in Fig. 1, which is the
most potent known topoisomerase I inhibitor among the indolocarbazole
derivatives (Bailly et al., 1997
). The interaction of this
indolocarbazole derivative with DNA has been examined by a combination
of spectroscopic and biochemical methods. Important information
concerning the contribution of its sugar residue to the interaction
with DNA has been obtained by comparing the binding properties of
R-3 with those of its aglycone R-4.
| |
Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Drugs.
The syntheses of the indolocarbazole R-3
and its aglycone derivative, R-4, have been reported
previously (Rodrigues-Pereira et al., 1996
). In the dry
state, the drugs were stored in a desiccator in the dark at 4°.
Ligand concentrations were determined by direct weighing. The two drugs
were dissolved in dimethylsulfoxide at 3 mg/ml and then diluted further
with water. Fresh dilutions were prepared immediately before use. The
final dimethylsulfoxide concentration never exceeded 0.3% (v/v) and
were always made under conditions in which dimethylsulfoxide (also
present in the controls) is known not to affect nuclease activity (Drew
and Travers, 1984
).
Chemicals and biochemicals.
Calf thymus DNA and the
double-stranded polymers poly(dA/dT)·poly(dA/dT) and
poly(dG/dC)·poly(dG/dC) were from Sigma (La Verpillière, France). Their concentrations were determined through the application of molar extinction coefficients of 6600, 6600, and 8400 M
1
cm
1, respectively. Calf thymus DNA was
deproteinized with sodium dodecyl sulfate (protein content, <0.2%),
and all nucleic acids were dialyzed against 1 m[scap]m sodium
cacodylate buffer, pH 6.5. Nucleoside triphosphates labeled with
[
-32P]dATP and
[
-32P]ATP were obtained from Amersham
International (Buckinghamshire, UK). Restriction endonucleases
AvaI, EcoRI, and PvuII; alkaline phosphatase; T4 polynucleotide kinase; avian myeloblastosis virus reverse transcriptase, T4 DNA ligase; and exonuclease III were purchased from Boehringer-Mannheim Biochemica (Mannheim, Germany) and
used according to the supplier's recommended protocol in the activity
buffer provided. All other chemicals were analytical grade reagents,
and all solutions were prepared using doubly deionized, filtered water.
Absorption spectroscopy and estimation of binding constants.
Absorption spectra were recorded on a Perkin-Elmer Cetus (Norwalk, CT)
Lambda 5 spectrophotometer using a 10-mm optical pathlength. Titrations
of the drugs with DNA, covering a wide range of drug/DNA-phosphate ratios, were performed by the addition of aliquots of a concentrated DNA solution to a drug solution at a constant ligand concentration (20 µM). Binding parameters were determined using
experimental spectrophotometric readings from absorbance titration
experiments conducted at 320 nm. The apparent association constant
K (M
1) and number of
sites per nucleotide (n) were estimated from Scatchard plots using two models: (1) the noncooperative overlapping binding site
model of McGhee and von Hippel (1974)
and (2) a two-site model that
assumes the existence of two independent types of noncooperative binding sites. A better adjustment of the parameters to fit the experimental data could be obtained with the McGhee-von Hippel model
than with the two-site model. The program Inplot 4 (Graphpad, San
Diego, CA) (Leatherbarrow, 1990
) was used to obtain the best fit of the
data to each of these two models.
A/A, and response time of 3 msec. All experiments were conducted at
20° with a 10-mm-pathlength Kerr cell with 1.5-mm electrode
separation in 1 mM sodium cacodylate buffer, pH 6.5.
DNA purification and labeling.
Plasmids pBS (Stratagene, La
Jolla, CA) and pKMp27 (Drew et al., 1985
) were isolated from
Escherichia coli by a standard sodium dodecyl sulfate-sodium
hydroxide lysis procedure and purified by banding in CsCl-ethidium
bromide gradients. Ethidium was removed through several isopropanol
extractions followed by exhaustive dialysis against Tris-EDTA buffer.
The purified plasmid then was precipitated and resuspended in
appropriate buffer before digestion by the restriction enzymes. The two
pBS DNA fragments were prepared by 3
-32P-end
labeling of the EcoRI/PvuII double digest of the
plasmid using
-32P-dATP (6000 Ci/mmol) and
avian myeloblastosis virus reverse transcriptase or by
5
-32P-end labeling of the
EcoRI/alkaline phosphatase-treated plasmid using
-32P-ATP (6000 Ci/mmol) and T4 polynucleotide
kinase followed by treatment with PvuII. Similarly, the
tyrT fragment was prepared by 3
- or 5
-end labeling of the
EcoRI/AvaI digest of plasmid pKMp27. In each
case, the digestion products were separated on a 6% polyacrylamide gel
under native conditions in Tris/borate/EDTA buffer (89 mM
Tris-borate, pH 8.3, 1 mM EDTA). After autoradiography, the
band of DNA was excised, crushed, and soaked in elution buffer (500 mM ammonium acetate, 10 mM magnesium acetate)
overnight at 37°. This suspension was filtered through a 0.22-µm
Millipore filter, and the DNA was precipitated with ethanol. After
washing with 70% ethanol and vacuum-drying of the precipitate, the
labeled DNA was resuspended in 10 mM Tris, adjusted to pH
7.0, containing 10 mM NaCl.
-AATTCCGGTTACCTTTAATC and 5
-TCGGGAACCCCCACCACGGG bearing a 5
-OH or
5
-NH2 terminal group to permit
5
-phosphorylation of one strand only. The template 160-bp
tyrT(A93) fragment containing the E. coli tyrT
promoter (Drew and Travers, 1984
-phosphate
due to the action of EcoRI, and thus only the newly
synthesized DNA (with normal or modified nucleotides) could be labeled
by the kinase. Twenty amplification cycles were performed, with each cycle consisting of the following segments: (1) for normal, DAP-DNA, U-DNA, MeC-DNA, and U + MeC DNA: 94° for 1 min, 37° for 2 min, and
72° for 10 min; and (2) for I-DNA and I + DAP-DNA: 84° for 1 min,
30° for 2 min, and 62° for 10 min. The purified PCR products were
5
-end labeled with
-32P-ATP in the presence
of T4 polynucleotide kinase, and the labeled DNA was isolated by 6%
polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis.
DNA circularization assay.
Experiments were performed with
either the 32P-labeled 160-bp
tyrT(A93) fragment from plasmid pKMp27 or directly with the
plasmid linearized with EcoRI. The experimental protocol has
been described recently (Bailly et al., 1996c
). Briefly,
each sample consisted of 3 µl of DNA containing 0.5 µg of
linearized plasmid DNA or ~0.3 ng (50 cps) of the 160-mer
32P-labeled EcoRI restriction
fragment, 3 µl of water, 10 µl of drug at the desired concentration
(or water in the controls), and 2 µl of 10× ligase buffer. After a
30-min incubation to ensure equilibration, 1 µl (5 units) of ligase
was added to each tube, and the reaction was continued at room
temperature (~20°) for 30 min. The ligase was denatured by heating
at 65° for 5 min, and samples were electrophoresed immediately. To
verify that the ligation products corresponded to circular DNA
molecules, 1 µl of exonuclease III (50 units) was added to the
ligase-treated sample (after the heat denaturation step) and incubated
for 30 min at 37° before electrophoresis.
Electrophoresis and quantification by storage phosphor imaging. DNA cleavage products were resolved by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis under denaturing conditions (0.3-mm-thick 8% acrylamide containing 8 M urea). After electrophoresis (~2.5 hr at 60 W, 1600 V in Tris/borate/EDTA buffer), gels were soaked in 10% acetic acid for 10 min, transferred to Whatman (Maidstone, UK) 3MM paper, and dried under vacuum at 80°. A Molecular Dynamics 425E PhosphorImager (Sunnyvale, CA) was used to collect data from the storage screens exposed to dried gels overnight at room temperature. Base-line-corrected scans were analyzed by integrating all the densities between two selected boundaries using ImageQuant software (v. 3.3; Sunnyvale, CA). Each resolved band was assigned to a particular bond within the DNA fragment by comparison of its position relative to sequencing standards generated by treatment of the DNA with dimethylsulfate (G) and/or formic acid (G + A) followed by piperidine-induced cleavage at the modified bases in DNA.
| |
Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
DNA binding.
Spectrophotometry reveals that the binding of the
rebeccamycin derivative R-3 to DNA results in a large
absorbance decrease in the 280-360-nm spectral region of the drug,
whereas the addition of DNA to the sugar-free indolocarbazole analogue R-4 has little effect on its absorption spectrum (Fig. 2). A 28% hypochromism is observed in
the 330-nm band of R-3 (at P/D = 30), whereas the
hypochromism does not exceed 6% with R-4 precluding an
accurate estimate of the binding affinity for this compound. The
affinity of R-3 for calf thymus DNA was determined from the
binding measurements using Scatchard analysis (Fig.
3). We could secure an acceptable fit to
the data using the orthodox McGhee-von Hippel analysis (McGhee and von Hippel, 1974
) but not with other models for a single class of binding
sites. The binding constant calculated for R-3 is 1.75 ± 0.035 × 105
M
1. It falls within the range of
values reported for weak intercalating drugs, such as the acridine
derivative amsacrine (Wilson et al., 1981
). Although
the strength of interaction between R-4 and DNA is too weak
to measure accurately, we can estimate that the affinity constant for
the aglycone must be
1 order of magnitude lower than that of
R-3. There thus is no doubt that the carbohydrate moiety of
R-3 contributes positively and significantly to the binding
affinity.
|
|
Intercalation into DNA.
Electric linear dichroism was used to
compare the mode of binding of rebeccamycin (R-1),
R-3, and R-4. As shown in Fig.
4A, the reduced dichroism measured at 320 nm with rebeccamycin or R-3 bound to DNA is slightly higher than that obtained with DNA alone at 260 nm, whereas that measured with
R-4 in the presence of DNA is considerably weaker. These
data indicate that in complexes formed with both drugs possessing the
sugar residue, the chromophore is oriented parallel to the plane of the
base pairs, as is the case with an intercalated drug. The results
corroborate the initial hypothesis of Yamashita et al.
(1992)
and our recent measurements (Bailly et al., 1997
)
that compounds such as rebeccamycin and R-3 (which bear the same sugar) intercalate into DNA.
|
Effect on DNA structure and flexibility.
For a first series of
experiments, we resorted to the linear plasmid DNA ligation assay using
T4 DNA ligase, which has been used to characterize the effect of
intercalating agents, including adriamycin, amsacrine, and certain
indolocarbazole derivatives (Yamashita et al., 1992
). The
linear pKMp27 DNA (cut with EcoRI) was treated with DNA
ligase in the presence of increasing concentrations of R-3
and R-4. The gel in Fig. 5A
shows unambiguously that the two indolocarbazole compounds have
different effects on the rate of formation of circular DNA molecules
and multimers. The ligation pattern observed with R-4, even
at a high concentration, is indistinguishable from that seen in the
control lanes with no drug present. In contrast, the addition of
R-3 significantly changes the electrophoretic distribution
of ligation products. With R-3, but not with R-4,
a DNA species that comigrates with the supercoiled DNA (native plasmid)
is formed. Moreover, R-3 is much more efficient than the
aglycone at promoting the formation of supercoiled dimers. These data
suggest that the carbohydrate moiety attached to the chromophore must increase the curvature of DNA and/or its intrinsic flexibility so as to
facilitate the formation of circular products.
|
10 µM, the electrophoretic mobility of the circular DNA
species is considerably reduced, whereas that of the linear DNA remains
unaffected. It seems that R-3 binds preferentially to the
circular DNA species rather than the linear species.
The consistent observation that R-3 and R-4
interfere differently with the closure reaction confirms that they exert different effects on DNA structure. The data in Fig. 5, A and B,
indicate that the methoxyglucose residue always affects the induction
or recognition of circular DNA molecules by R-3, which
implies that it contributes directly to processes connected with
flexibility. Although the possible bending of DNA by R-3 remains speculative at present, it is quite conceivable that some such
subtle effect on DNA structure could contribute to the mechanism by
which the drug inhibits topoisomerase I.
Sequence selective binding.
Footprinting studies were
performed using the endonuclease DNase I, which has been used
extensively in our laboratory over many years for mapping the
DNA-binding sites of a large variety of drugs endowed with
antimicrobial, antiviral, and antitumor properties (Waring and Bailly,
1994
). Three different DNA restriction fragments, isolated from the
plasmids pKMp27 and pBS and 3
- or 5
-end labeled on one or the other
of the complementary strands, were used as substrates. A typical
autoradiograph of a sequencing gel used to fractionate the products of
partial digestion of the DNA complexed with R-3 is presented
in Fig. 6. With the drug bound, the DNase
I cleavage pattern differs significantly from that seen in the control
lane. Numerous bands in the drug-containing lanes are weaker than the
same bands in the drug-free lane, corresponding to attenuated cleavage,
whereas others display relative enhancement of cutting. Many other gels
(not shown) using different concentrations of R-3 were run
and used for the quantification.
|
15 µg/ml, and the footprinting profiles remain practically unchanged at
concentrations of
60 µg/ml. The plots in Fig. 7B compare the footprinting data obtained with R-3 and its aglycone
R-4 (both at 60 µg/ml). Although the footprints are much
more pronounced with R-3 than with R-4, the two
drugs bind at essentially identical sites. The weak footprints produced
by R-4 surely correlate with its low affinity for DNA.
Nevertheless, it seems that the sequence selectivity is driven
principally by the indolocarbazole chromophore rather than by the
carbohydrate moiety, which serves mainly to anchor the drug on the
helix.
|
-CGCGCCG from positions
73-79 corresponds to a region of enhanced cleavage. A search for the
common denominator of the binding sites for R-3 suggests
that with few exceptions, the rebeccamycin analogue is binding
preferentially to 5
-YpGpT-ApCpR and 5
-RpTpG-CpApY sites but not to
CpG or GpC steps. The strongest binding site in the 160-mer fragment
encompasses the sequence TGTTACGTT, which contains three juxtaposed
GpT/TpG steps. This GT-rich sequence was also protected from cleavage
in experiments in which DNase II and micrococcal nuclease were used as
footprinting probes (data not shown). With all three fragments tested,
the sequences protected from DNase I cutting in the presence of
R-3 contain at least one GpT or TpG site (Fig. 7C). In every
experiment, the same sequences were found to be protected (weakly but
significantly) by the addition of R-4, reinforcing the
conclusion that the indolocarbazole chromophore, not the appended
carbohydrate moiety, must be responsible to a large extent for the
sequence selectivity.
Effects of the exocyclic substituents at TpG and GpT sites.
In
previous studies, we have shown that the exocyclic substituents of DNA
bases, especially the 2-amino group of guanine, play a determinant role
in specific recognition of DNA sequences by small molecules and
proteins (Bailly et al., 1995
, 1996c
; Bailly and Waring,
1995a
, 1995c
). By analogy, we hypothesized that the exocyclic
substituents at GpT and TpG sites must contribute to the selective
binding of R-3 to TG/GT-containing sequences. This
hypothesis was put to the test by synthesizing two series of DNA
molecules in which the position of the exocyclic substituents, namely
the guanine amino group and the thymine methyl group, are varied.
terminal nucleotide residue bore a
5
-NH2 terminal group instead of a conventional 5
-OH was used to enable selective labeling of the sense (Crick) strand
in the PCR product. In each case, the DNA was incubated with
R-3 for 20 min at 37° to establish equilibrium before exposure of the samples to the nicking activity of DNase I.
|
-CTTT·AAAG in normal DNA does not afford a receptor site
for R-3, whereas the corresponding DAP-containing sequence, 5
-CTTT·DDDI, proves to be an excellent receptor for the drug. Similar trends appear at two other sites, DTDT and TDTC, indicated in
Fig. 9. The footprinting patterns determined with the doubly substituted I + DAP DNA resemble those obtained with the DAP DNA, whereas those seen with the Inosine DNA do not differ greatly from
those observed with normal DNA. The new binding sites at TpD or DpT
sequences reinforce the belief that the drug prefers TpG or GpT steps
in natural DNA. Indeed, viewed from the minor groove, TpG and GpT steps
are equivalent to TpD and DpT steps, respectively, in terms of
hydrogen-bond potential. Therefore, the data suggest that the purine
2-amino group normally present on guanine that occupies the minor
groove of DNA acts as a positive element that drives the selective
binding of R-3 to TpG or GpT sites.
|
|
| |
Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The spectroscopic data reported here together with the previous
results of others (Yamashita et al., 1992
) as well as
ourselves (Bailly et al., 1997
) leave no room for doubt that
rebeccamycin analogues such as R-3 intercalate into DNA.
However, if the intercalation of the planar indolocarbazole chromophore
is beyond dispute, one question remains concerning the location of the
carbohydrate moiety when the drug is bound to DNA. Does the methoxyglucose residue of R-3 locate in the minor or the major groove of the double helix, or does it simply extend out from the
helix? As far as the present data indicate, it must be acknowledged
that the probable location of the sugar moiety has not been
demonstrated directly, although it is certain that it contributes
significantly to the interaction with nucleic acids. It would be hard
to imagine that the carbohydrate residue plays no part in the
interaction of the drug with its cellular targets, given the
unequivocal evidence for the difference between R-3 and its
aglycone R-4 regarding DNA-binding affinity but also in
terms of topoisomerase I inhibition and cytotoxicity (Bailly et
al., 1997
; Rodrigues-Pereira et al., 1996
).
At first sight, it seems logical to suggest that the carbohydrate
occupies the minor groove when the drug chromophore is intercalated between consecutive base pairs. With the vast majority of DNA-binding small molecules equipped with carbohydrate groups, the sugar moiety nestles within the minor groove of the helix and participates positively in the DNA recognition process. This is the case for the
well known anthracycline antibiotics (e.g., adriamycin) (Chaires, 1996
)
as well as the enediyne antibiotics (e.g., calicheamicin) (Kumar
et al., 1997
) and many other antitumor agents, such as mithramycin and chromomycin (Keniry et al., 1993
). Moreover,
the fact that addition, deletion, or relocation of the 2-amino group of
guanine residues affects the sequence-selective binding of R-3 to DNA indicates that the drug must somehow sense the presence of a substituent on the edges of the bases in the minor groove. The exocyclic amino group is the only hydrogen-bond donor exposed in the minor groove, and we demonstrated previously that this
group serves as a key element for minor groove recognition by small
molecules as well as by proteins (Bailly et al., 1995
, 1996c
; Bailly and Waring, 1995a
, 1995c
). In this regard, the
rebeccamycin analogue R-3 does not escape the rule because
its interaction with TG/GT sites evidently depends on the position of
the purine amino substituent in the minor groove. However, the totality
of the situation cannot be so simple, and some involvement with the major groove cannot be excluded for several reasons. The chief finding
is that as judged on the basis of the footprinting data in Fig. 10, the
methyl group of thymine must also contribute to the interaction between
the drug and its preferred sites. With all the antibiotics and small
molecules studied previously, relocation of the methyl group of thymine
has had little or no influence on the sequence-selective interaction
between the drug and DNA. For example, the methyl group can be
eliminated completely without perturbing the AT-specific minor groove
binding of netropsin and distamycin or the GC-specific intercalative
binding of echinomycin and actinomycin, which also occupy the minor
groove. So far as we are aware, this is the only known instance in
which the transfer of the methyl group from thymines to cytosines
(T-to-5MeC substitution) suffices to create new and strongly favored
drug-binding sites. This key observation suggests that in one way or
another, the drug must establish contacts with the DNA via the major
groove of the double helix.
It is important to mention that the footprinting patterns determined
here with R-3 are strongly reminiscent of those obtained
previously with nogalamycin (Fox and Waring, 1986
) and certain
bisnaphthalimide derivatives (Bailly et al., 1996a
).
Nogalamycin is an intercalative antibiotic containing a planar
anthracycline chromophore substituted with two bulky carbohydrate
groups that come to lie simultaneously in the minor and major grooves
of the double helix at DNA sequences containing GpT and/or TpG steps (Smith et al., 1995
). Recently, we not only reported that a
series of tumor active bisnaphthalimide derivatives exhibit a sharp
selectivity for TG/GT-containing sequences but also presented strong
evidence that these bisintercalating drugs recognize DNA sequences via major groove contacts (Bailly et al., 1996a
). Our present
footprinting studies show that R-3 shares with nogalamycin
and the bisnaphthalimides the rare property of interacting selectively
with TpG- and GpT-containing sequences. The correspondence between the
footprinting profiles obtained with R-3 and major groove
binding drugs such as nogalamycin and the bisnaphthalimides, on the one
hand, and the observation that the methyl group of thymine is a key
element for the selective binding of R-3 to TG/GT sites, on
the other, lead us to hypothesize that the sugar probably is located in
the minor groove although the large planar chromophore extends well
into the major groove of DNA. Although the elucidation of exactly how
R-3 interacts with DNA must await more precise structural
investigations (NMR and X-ray studies are in progress), we have adduced
good reason to believe that the drug uses both exocyclic substituents
of DNA exposed in the minor and the major grooves to recognize
selectively TpG- and GpT-containing sequences. This unusual
characteristic may be exploitable for targeting specific sites in
genes.
The last point to consider is the relationship between the
drug-stimulated cleavage sites on DNA in the presence of topoisomerase I and the preferred drug-binding sites. In general, binding to DNA and
topoisomerase inhibition are best viewed as two distinct molecular
processes contributing separately to the cytotoxic activity because in
nearly all cases, the known sequence selectivity of drug binding to DNA
has little to do with the location of drug-induced topoisomerase II
breaks. For example, the topoisomerase II inhibitor doxorubicin binds
preferentially to A/TGC and A/TCG triplets (Chaires et al.,
1990
), whereas doxorubicin-induced topoisomerase II strand breaks can
occur at many types of sites not necessarily encompassing the
aforementioned triplets. The presence of an adenine residue at position
1 relative to the cleavage site (T at +5) is the only requirement for
doxorubicin-stabilized cleavage of DNA by topoisomerase II (Capranico
et al., 1990
). Actinomycin D, which can inhibit both
topoisomerase I and topoisomerase II, exhibits a sharp selectivity for
GpC-containing sites (Bailly et al., 1994
), but no specific
sequence requirement for topoisomerase inhibition has been reported.
Conversely, cleavage sites produced by topoisomerase I in response to
camptothecin derivatives show a preponderance of G at the +1 position
(Pommier et al., 1993
), whereas the drug interacts loosely,
if at all, with DNA in the absence of the enzyme. Thus, most studies
have failed to find a correlation between the sequence selectivity of
drug binding to (protein-free) DNA and effects on topoisomerases, but
here the correlation is good. So far as we can tell, this is the first
case in which the sequence selectivity of a drug coincides well with
the topoisomerase I-mediated cleavage selectivity (Fig. 7A). It is
refreshingly clear that the rebeccamycin analogue R-3
prefers TpG sequences, and we have recently shown that it stabilizes
topoisomerase I preferentially at sites with a T and a G on the 5
and
3
side of the cleaved bond, respectively (Bailly et al.,
1997
). It would be a cruel coincidence if the preferred binding sites
identified in our footprinting experiments were to play no part in
determination of the effect of the drug on topoisomerase I cleavage
reactions. Accordingly, the current results set the stage for the
design of more effective rebeccamycin analogues.
| |
Acknowledgments |
|---|
C.B. and M.J.W. thank Chris Koncewicz for his helpful contribution to the footprinting experiments and Julie Morgan for expert technical assistance.
| |
Footnotes |
|---|
Received July 23, 1997; Accepted September 18, 1997
This work was supported by research grants from the Association pour la Recherche sur le Cancer (Grant ARC6932) (C.B.) and the Fédération Nationale des Groupements des Entreprises Français dans la Lutte contre le Cancer; (M.J.W.) from the Cancer Research Campaign, the Wellcome Trust, Association for International Cancer Research, and the Sir Halley Stewart Trust. Support by the convention INSERM-CFB is acknowledged.
Send reprint requests to: Dr. Christian Bailly, IRCL-INSERM U124, Place de Verdun, 59045 Lille cedex, France. E-mail: bailly{at}lille.inserm.fr
| |
Abbreviations |
|---|
bp, base pair; I, inosine; U, uracil; DAP, 2,6-diaminopurine; PCR, polymerase chain reaction; 5MeC, 5-methylcytosine.
| |
References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
-D-glucopyranosyl)-5H-indolo[2,3-a]pyrrolo-[3,4-c]carbazole-5,7-(6H)-dione (NB-506): its potent antitumor activities in mice.
Cancer Res
55:
1316-1320
(A/T)CG and 5
(A/T)GC sequences revealed by footprinting titration experiments.
Biochemistry
29:
6145-6153[Medline].
1I-DNA complex.
J Mol Biol
265:
187-201[Medline].
-9-acridinylamino)methanesulphon-m-anisidide and related acridines with nucleic acids.
Mol Pharmacol
20:
404-414
-D-glucopyranosyl)-5H-indolo[2,3-a]pyrrolo-[3,4-c]carbazole-5,7-(6H)-dione (NB-506): induction of topoisomerase I-mediated DNA cleavage and mechanisms of cell line-selective cytotoxicity.
Cancer Res
55:
1310-1315This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
B. Cheng, I-F. Liu, and Y.-C. Tse-Dinh Compounds with antibacterial activity that enhance DNA cleavage by bacterial DNA topoisomerase I J. Antimicrob. Chemother., April 1, 2007; 59(4): 640 - 645. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. D. Ricart, L. A. Hammond, J. G. Kuhn, C. H. Takimoto, A. Goetz, B. Forouzesh, L. Forero, J. L. Ochoa-Bayona, K. Berg, A. W. Tolcher, et al. Phase I and Pharmacokinetic Study of Sequences of the Rebeccamycin Analogue NSC 655649 and Cisplatin in Patients with Advanced Solid Tumors Clin. Cancer Res., December 15, 2005; 11(24): 8728 - 8736. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Y. Chen, S.-J. Shih, M. Hsiao, M. L. Rothenberg, and M. Prudhomme Induction of Radiosensitization by Indolocarbazole Derivatives: The Role of DNA Topoisomerase I Mol. Pharmacol., September 1, 2004; 66(3): 553 - 560. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. Carrasco, M. Facompre, J. D. Chisholm, D. L. Van Vranken, W. D. Wilson, and C. Bailly DNA sequence recognition by the indolocarbazole antitumor antibiotic AT2433-B1 and its diastereoisomer Nucleic Acids Res., April 15, 2002; 30(8): 1774 - 1781. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. H. Woo, J. R. Vance, A. R. O. Marcos, C. Bailly, and M.-A. Bjornsti Active Site Mutations in DNA Topoisomerase I Distinguish the Cytotoxic Activities of Camptothecin and the Indolocarbazole, Rebeccamycin J. Biol. Chem., February 1, 2002; 277(6): 3813 - 3822. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||