Department of Neurophysiology, University of Wisconsin-Madison,
Madison, Wisconsin 53706
 |
Introduction |
GABAA
receptors are the major inhibitory neurotransmitter receptors in the
mammalian brain and are members of a ligand-gated ion channel
superfamily (Ortells and Lunt, 1995
), which includes receptors for
acetylcholine, glycine, and serotonin. Molecular cloning studies have
identified several different classes and isoforms of
GABAA receptor subunits, including 6
, 4
,
3
,1
, and 2
subunit subtypes (Sieghart, 1995
). The majority
of the GABAA receptors in the brain are likely to
consist of
1,
2, and
2 subunits (Stephenson, 1995
). These
receptors are pentameric proteins containing an integral
chloride-selective channel with specific binding sites for GABA, BZDs,
barbiturates, steroids, and picrotoxin (Sieghart, 1995
; Smith and
Olsen, 1995
). BZDs, clinically used for their anxiolytic,
muscle-relaxant, sedative, and antiepileptic actions, exert their
therapeutic effects by allosterically modulating the activation of the
GABAA receptor. Because of their clinical
usefulness, a substantial effort has been made to understand the
structural determinants within the receptor that underlie BZD binding
and allosteric coupling.
Evidence suggests that both the
and
subunits play critical
roles in BZD binding and potentiation. By analogy to the agonist binding site of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (Karlin and Akabas, 1995
), the BZD binding site of the GABAA
receptor has been modeled with a
subunit apposed to an
subunit,
with adjacent faces of the subunits contributing to the binding site
(Smith and Olsen, 1995
). Alternatively, any subunit may bind BZD itself but have this ability enhanced by conformational changes conferred by
the presence of the
subunit, which is required for high affinity BZD effects (Pritchett et al., 1989
). Regardless,
understanding the roles of the
and
subunits in BZD binding and
modulation requires discovery of the specific structural elements
involved.
In the
1 subunit, several amino acid residues have been identified
that are important for BZD effects. Photoaffinity-labeling (Smith and
Olsen, 1995
; Duncalfe et al., 1996
) and mutagenesis experiments (Wieland et al., 1992
; Kleingoor et
al., 1993
) have identified histidine at position 101 (H101) as
forming part of the BZD binding site. Experiments using
1/
3
chimeras point to
1G200 as another potential site for BZD effects
(Pritchett and Seeburg, 1991
). Other residues in
1 implicated in BZD
binding include T162 and V211 (Wieland and Luddens, 1994
), Y161 and
T206 (Buhr et al., 1996
), and Y159 and Y209 (Amin et
al., 1997
). Taken together, these results suggest that three
separate domains of the
1 subunit, near H101, Y159-T162, and
G200-V211, are involved in BZD binding.
Less evidence has been gathered regarding the BZD-responsive regions of
the
subunit. Mutagenesis experiments have identified two amino
acids (F77 and T142) in the
2 subunit that may play a role in BZD
effects. Mutation of Thr142 to serine (
2T142S) altered the efficacy
of several BZD ligands; both an antagonist (Ro15-1788) and a weak
inverse agonist (Ro15-4513) took on the character of partial agonists
(Mihic et al., 1994
). Mutation of Phe77 to leucine
(
2F77L) enhanced diazepam potentiation of the GABA-mediated
Cl
current (Buhr et al., 1996
), even
though the binding affinity of diazepam was reduced. Substitution of
2F77 with other amino acids had complex effects on BZD pharmacology
(Buhr et al., 1997
).
Both
2F77 and
2T142 are conserved in the aligned sequence of
1. The
subunit, even though it contains the homologous
phenylalanine and threonine residues, cannot substitute for a
subunit in conferring BZD effects. 
receptors do not bind BZDs or
exhibit BZD-induced potentiation of the GABA-activated
Cl
current, whereas 

receptors do.
Thus, other residues specific to the
subunit are required for BZD
binding and modulation.
To determine which regions unique to the
2S subunit confer BZD
binding and potentiation, we generated chimeric protein combinations of
rat
2S and
1 subunits. Chimeric studies have the potential to
target whole domains, which is important if we envision the drug
binding site as a pocket formed by the side chains of a variety of
amino acids from one or more regions of a subunit. Using this method,
we identified two domains of
2S that are, in conjunction, necessary
and sufficient for high affinity BZD binding. In addition, we
demonstrated that the
2S regions responsible for high affinity BZD
binding are distinct from the
2S regions necessary for efficient allosteric coupling of the BZD binding site to the GABA binding site.
The construction of chimeric subunits that exhibit wild-type binding
but reduced allosteric coupling of GABA and BZD binding sites affords
new probes for elucidating the structural components of allosteric
modulation.
 |
Materials and Methods |
Molecular cloning.
Chimeras (
) were generated by placing
the rat
2 coding region 5
to and in register with the rat
1
sequence in pBlueScript SK
(Stratagene, La
Jolla, CA). The dual plasmid (pTRCP, Fig.
1A) was digested, and the linearized
plasmid was recircularized in bacteria by random homologous crossover
events (Moore and Blakely, 1994
). To create chimeric subunits
containing amino-terminal domains of the
2S subunit and
carboxyl-terminal domains of the
1 subunit, we cut the dual-subunit
plasmid with a restriction enzyme that cuts only in each coding region
of
2S and
1 (either AflII or BbsI). A
fragment consisting mostly of the transmembrane and 3
coding regions
of
2S was released. The remaining linearized plasmid contained
2S
and
1 sequences with restricted regions of homology. Because
appropriate crossovers can occur only in a small area delimited by the
chosen restriction enzyme or enzymes, we named this method TRCP. Using
this method, dozens of chimeric subunits with crossovers in the 5
(extracellular) region were generated in XL1-Blue cells, an
endA
strain that facilitates plasmid
miniprep production. The chimeric open reading frames were subcloned
into pGH19 (Liman et al., 1992
; Robertson et al.,
1996
) for expression in oocytes or into pCEP4 (InVitrogen, San Diego,
CA) for transient expression in HEK 293 cells. For the TRCP chimeras
generated in this study (Fig. 1B), the
2S and
1 amino acids at
which the crossovers occur are
N40/
R28 (
40),
W82/
K70
(
82),
W107/
T95 (
107),
F113/
H101 (
113),
D161/
A149 (
161), and
L167/
K155 (
167). Chimeras
40,
82,
107, and
113 were generated by AflII digestion,
whereas
161 and
167 used BbsI digestion.

View larger version (29K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
TRCP. A, Chimeras were generated by placing the
2S coding region (2.0 kb) 5 to and in register with the 1
sequence (1.65 kb) in pBlueScript SK (2.9 kb; Stratagene)
to yield pTRCP (6.55 kb). When linearized and introduced into competent
coliform cells, the plasmid was recircularized by crossover events in
homologous regions within the plasmid construct (see Materials and
Methods). By choosing restriction enzymes that cut both 2S and 1
(e.g., AflII), the transmembrane and 3 coding region of
2 was released, and sufficient 1 and 2 5 sequence was left to
allow for crossover events. Black, 2S sequence.
White, 1 sequence. Gray, crossover
areas made available by digestion with AflII. B, TRCP
chimeras were screened from four independent trials and contained 5
2S and 3 1 sequence, the amount of which was determined by
restriction digest mapping and DNA sequencing. The chimeras ( )
generated by TRCP are named for the amino acid of where the crossover
transitions occurs and fell into six major groups ( 40, 82,
107, 113, 161, and 167). Three additional non-TRCP chimeras
were made (see Materials and Methods) and are named for the 2S
segments each contains. For example, 40/114-161 contains 2S
sequence from Q1 to N40 and from R114 to D161. 114-161 contains
only 2S sequence from R114 to D161. Black, 2S
sequence. White, 1 sequence. Gray,
transmembrane segments M1 through M4.
|
|
Chimera
114-161 (Fig. 1B) was produced by recombinant polymerase
chain reaction using an oligonucleotide
(5
-CCAGTAAAATCTGGACTCCAGACACTTTCTTCAGGAACTCC-3
) designed to create an
F100/
R114 crossover. Using this 5
oligonucleotide and a
downstream complementary
1 oligonucleotide
(5
-CTGGGAGAGAATGACTGTC-3
) with chimera
161 as template, a 456-base
pair polymerase chain reaction fragment with
1 5
and 3
flanks and
2 114-161 sequence was generated and subcloned into wild-type
1
cDNA using BalI and NsiI. The resulting chimera
contained
1 sequence except in the region from H101 to D148. This
region contained the homologous
2 region (R114 to D161). Chimeras
40/114-161 and
82/114-161 (Fig. 1B) were produced by digesting
114-161 with MscI and NdeI, which flank the
2 114-161 sequence, and subcloning the resultant 749-base pair
fragment into
40 and
82. The resulting chimeras replaced the
1
region from H101 to D148 in both
40 and
82 with the homologous
2S region (R114-D161). All chimeras were verified by restriction
digest and double-stranded DNA sequencing using standard techniques
(Sambrook et al., 1989
).
Transient expression in HEK 293 cells.
Rat
1,
2,
2S, and chimeric subunit cDNAs were subcloned into the multiple
cloning site of a mammalian expression vector (pCEP4; InVitrogen) for
transient transfection of HEK 293 cells (American Type Culture
Collection CRL 1573). Cells were grown onto 100-mm tissue culture
dishes in minimum essential medium with Earle's salts (Life
Technologies, Grand Island, NY) containing 10% fetal bovine serum
(Hyclone Laboratories, New Brunswick, NJ) in a 37° incubator under a
5% CO2 atmosphere. Cells were cotransfected at
40-50% confluency with pCEP-
1, pCEP-
2, pCEP-
2, and/or
pCEP-
using a standard CaHPO4 method (Graham and Eb, 1973
). In
general, cells were transfected with equal ratios of subunit DNA (5 µg/subunit). Cells were harvested and membrane homogenates prepared
48-72 hr after transfection.
Binding assays.
Cells were scraped from the dishes and
pelleted by centrifugation (1000 × g, 10 min, 4°).
The cells were washed once and resuspended in a HEPES buffer containing
124 mM NaCl, 2.9 mM KCl, 1.3 mM
MgSO4, 1.2 mM
KH2PO4, 25.0 mM
HEPES, 5.2 mM D-glucose, and 2 mM
EDTA; pH 7.4 and homogenized using a Polytron homogenizer (Brinkmann Instruments, Westbury, NY). The homogenates were centrifuged
(30,000 × g, 20 min, 4°), and the resulting pellets
were resuspended in HEPES buffer. Protein concentrations were
determined using a Bradford assay (BioRad, Hercules, CA) with bovine
serum albumin as a standard.
For BZD saturation binding experiments, membrane homogenates (100 µg)
were incubated at room temperature with seven to nine concentrations of
[3H]flunitrazepam (86 Ci/mmol; DuPont-New
England Nuclear, Boston, MA) in the absence and presence of 20 µM diazepam or 100 µM flurazepam to
determine total and nonspecific binding, respectively (final volume,
250 µl). The unlabeled BZDs, flunitrazepam, diazepam, Ro15-1788, and
Ro15-4513 were generously supplied to us by Dr. Sepinwall (Hoffman-La
Roche, Nutley, NJ). Flurazepam was obtained from Research Biochemicals
(Natick, MA). [3H]Muscimol (15.7 Ci/mmol;
DuPont-New England Nuclear) binding experiments were performed
similarly; 1 mM GABA or 100 µM muscimol was
used to determine nonspecific binding. All points were determined in
triplicate. After reaching equilibrium, the incubations were vacuum
filtered through glass-fiber filters (Reeves Angels; Whatman, Clifton,
NJ) using a cell harvester (model MB-48; Brandel, Montreal, Quebec,
Canada) and washed with eight times with 0.25 ml of HEPES buffer.
Specific binding was defined as the amount of tritium bound in the
absence of displacing ligand minus the amount bound in the presence of
displacer. Nonspecific binding was ~20-30% of total binding at
KD concentrations of radioligand. In
general, KD and
Bmax were determined by fitting specific
binding data to a single site using the equation y = Bmax*x/(KD + x), where y is specifically bound dpm, and
x is the radiolabeled drug concentration (Prism; GraphPAD
Softward, San Diego, CA).
Competition experiments with various BZD-site ligands were done under
the same general conditions, except seven to nine concentrations of
nonradioactive competing ligand were used to displace specifically bound radioligand. Data were fit by using a nonlinear least-squares method to the equation y = Bmax/[1+
(x/IC50)], where y is the specifically bound dpm, Bmax is maximal
binding, and x is the concentration of displacing drug
(Prism). KI was calculated according to the Cheng-Prusoff/Chou equation (Cheng and Prusoff, 1973
; Chou, 1974
).
To measure GABA potentiation of
[3H]flunitrazepam binding (Czajkowski et
al., 1989
), membrane homogenates were incubated for 60 min at room
temperature with 3-5 nM
[3H]flunitrazepam in the presence of six
different concentrations of GABA (ranging from 100 nM to 10 µM) and then filtered as described. The potentiation was
calculated for each GABA concentration as follows: p = (dpmGABA/dpmcontrol)
1, where dpmGABA is the specific [3H]flunitrazepam bound in the presence of
GABA, and dpmcontrol is the specific
[3H]flunitrazepam bound in the absence of GABA.
Expression in oocytes.
Capped cRNA coding for the wild-type
and chimeric subunits was synthesized by in vitro
transcription from NheI-linearized cDNA template using the
mMessage mMachine T7 kit (Ambion, Austin, TX). Oocytes from
Xenopus laevis were prepared by incubating small pieces of
ovary in collagenase (2 mg/ml) in ND96/Ca2+-free
media containing 96 mM NaCl, 2 mM KCl, 1 mM MgCl2, and 5 mM HEPES,
pH 7.6, for 40 min at room temperature. The digested ovaries were
washed several times in ND96, followed by several washes in recording
solution (ND96 with 1.8 mM CaCl2).
Individual oocytes were defolliculated manually or en masse
by 40-min incubation at room temperature in osmotic shock solution (130 mM K2HPO4, 1 mg/ml bovine serum albumin, pH 6.5 with HCl; Pajor, 1995
) followed by
several washes in recording solution. Within 1 day, they were injected
with 5-50 nl of mRNA (10-200 pg/nl/subunit) mixed in a ratio of 1:1
(
:
,
:
, or
:
) or 1:1:10 (
:
:
or
:
:
). These ratios were determined to produce maximal assembly of
- or
-containing channels (Boileau AJ and Czajkowski C. Improved measurements of GABA-elicited currents and diazepam potentiation in
recombinant GABAA receptor channels expressed in
Xenopus oocytes, manuscript in preparation). Oocytes were
stored at 17-19° in recording solution supplemented with 100 µg/ml
gentamicin and 100 µg/ml bovine serum albumin and were used for
electrophysiological experiments 2-14 days after injection. The total
amount of cRNA was scaled to yield maximal GABA-induced currents of
~3-8 µA for
1
2
2S and
1
2
. The
2
2S and
2
subunit combinations yielded less current, usually 0.5-3 µA.
cRNA concentrations were calculated by UV absorption and corroborated
by comparison with RNA standards on 1.5% agarose gels.
Voltage-clamp analysis.
Oocytes under two-electrode
voltage-clamp (Vhold =
80 mV) were perfused
continuously with ND96/Ca2+ recording solution at
a rate of 5 ml/min. In general, drugs and reagents were dissolved in
ND96/Ca2+. The stock diazepam solution was made
in dimethylsulfoxide. No differences in currents were observed with the
vehicle. GABA responses were scaled for run-down or run-up by
comparison with a low, nondesensitizing concentration of drug applied
just before the drug concentration tested. Diazepam potentiation was
recorded at ~EC7 to EC20
for GABA (1 µM GABA for
1
2
2S and
1
2
, 40 µM GABA for
2
2S). Potentiation is defined as
[I(GABA +
DZ)/IGABA)
1], where I(GABA + DZ) is the current response in the
presence of diazepam, and IGABA is the control
GABA current. Standard two-electrode voltage-clamp recording was
performed using a GeneClamp 500 (Axon Instruments, Burlingame, CA)
interfaced to a computer with an IT-16 A/D device (Instrutech, Great
Neck, NY). Electrodes were filled with 3 M KCl and had a
resistance of 0.5-1.5 M
.
Data acquisition and analysis were performed using AxoData, AxoGraph
(Axon Instruments), and Prism (GraphPAD Software, San Diego, CA). All
statistical comparisons used Student's t test for
independent samples (Snedecor and Cochran, 1980
).
 |
Results |
BZD and GABA Binding to 

Receptors
To create chimeric subunits containing amino-terminal domains of
the
2S subunit and carboxyl-terminal domains of the
1 subunit, we
modified a published method (Moore and Blakely, 1994
) to specifically target crossovers to occur in the extracellular amino-terminal domain
before M1 (see Materials and Methods; Fig. 1A). Chimeras (
) used
here, named for the
2S amino acid at which the crossovers occur, are
40,
82,
107,
113,
161, and
167 (Fig. 1B).
To determine whether the chimeric subunits contained appropriate
2S
domains for BZD binding, they were individually expressed with
wild-type
1 and
2 subunits in HEK 293 cells to form
1
2
receptors, and the binding of 100 nM
[3H]flunitrazepam was measured. Only two
chimeras,
161 and
167, which contain the amino-terminal 161 or
167 amino acid residues of the
2S subunit, exhibited significant
levels of specific [3H]flunitrazepam binding
(Fig. 2). No significant specific
[3H]flunitrazepam binding was detected after
expression of single subunits of wild-type or chimeric origin;
two-subunit combinations using
1
2,
1
2S,
2
2S, or
2
; or
1
2
combinations with
40,
82,
107, or
113.

View larger version (18K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
  161 and   167 receptors bind
[3H]flunitrazepam. Chimeric subunits were individually
expressed with wild-type 1 and 2 subunits in HEK 293 cells, and
the binding of 100 nM [3H]flunitrazepam was
measured (see Materials and Methods). Note that only two chimeras,
161 and 167, which contain the amino-terminal 161 and 167 amino
acid residues of the 2 sequence respectively, specifically bound
[3H]flunitrazepam. Percentages were calculated by
normalizing specific [3H]flunitrazepam binding of
1 2 2S, 1 2, or 1 2 receptors to 1 2 2S
binding. Results are mean ± standard error. The number of
individual experiments are shown in parentheses.
|
|
The affinity of
1
2
2S,
1
2
161, and
1
2
167
receptors for [3H]flunitrazepam (BZD agonist),
Ro15-1788 (BZD antagonist), and Ro15-4513 (BZD inverse agonist) was
measured by radioligand saturation and competition experiments to
determine whether
161- and
167-containing receptors were altered
in their ability to bind different classes of BZDs. Results from
saturation binding experiments demonstrated that
1
2
161 and
1
2
167 receptors had Bmax values
and equilibrium dissociation constants
(KD) for
[3H]flunitrazepam similar to those of
1
2
2S receptors, with KD values of 13.3, 11.3, and 9.9 nM, respectively
(Fig. 3, Table 1). Competition binding experiments using
Ro15-1788 or Ro15-4513 showed no significant differences from
1
2
2S in the KI values for
these compounds (Table 1).

View larger version (15K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Saturation binding of
[3H]flunitrazepam to membranes prepared from
HEK 293 cells expressing 1 2 2 and
1 2 161 receptors. KD and
Bmax values for
[3H]flunitrazepam were calculated by nonlinear
least-squares fit of specifically bound [3H]flunitrazepam
(see Materials and Methods). Data shown are from a single experiment
repeated multiple times with similar results; points,
mean ± standard error of triplicate determinations. Results are
summarized in Table 1.
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 1
Binding affinities for three different types of BZDs using wild-type
and chimeric receptors
The affinity of 1 2 2S, 1 2 161, and 1 2 167
receptors for [3H]flunitrazepam (BZD agonist), Ro15-1788 (BZD
antagonist), and Ro15-4513 (BZD inverse agonist) was measured by
radioligand saturation and competition binding experiments.
1 2 161 and 1 2 167 receptors had an affinity similar to
that of 1 2 2S for all three types of BZD-site ligands tested.
Results shown are mean ± standard error; n is the
number of independent experiments.
|
|
The dissociation constants for [3H]muscimol
binding (a GABA binding site agonist) to
1
2,
1
2
2S, and
1
2
161 receptors also were determined. The affinity and
Bmax values for
[3H]muscimol binding to
161-containing
receptors were similar to
1
2
2S receptors (
1
2
161:
KD = 88.3 ± 5.9 nM, Bmax = 1.32 ± 0.19 pmol/mg, 3 experiments;
1
2
2S:
KD = 70.0 ± 8.0 nM, Bmax = 1.21 ± 0.18 pmol/mg, 20 experiments).
1
2 receptors bound
[3H]muscimol with a ~2-fold higher affinity
(KD = 46.2 ± 9.0 nM, Bmax = 1.23 ± 0.14 pmol/mg, 5 experiments).1 The small but
significant difference in [3H]muscimol affinity
in
1
2
2S and
1
2
161 receptors versus
1
2 receptors
(p < 0.01) may be diagonistic for the presence
of
2 domains in the pentameric receptor complex.
Allosteric Coupling of the GABA and BZD Binding Sites
Two-electrode voltage-clamp studies.
Because robust BZD
binding does not necessarily indicate functional coupling of the BZD
and GABA binding sites, the chimeras were tested with two-electrode
voltage-clamp for the ability of diazepam to potentiate the
GABA-mediated Cl
current.
40,
82,
107,
and
113 showed no diazepam potentiation of the GABA response when
coexpressed with wild-type
1 and
2 cRNA in X. laevis
oocytes, whereas
161 and
167 exhibited small but detectable
amounts of potentiation. The traces in Fig.
4A show diazepam potentiation of
GABA-activated currents from oocytes expressing
1
2
2S,
1
2
161, and
1
2
167 GABAA
receptors. Fig. 4B plots the potentiation of GABA-activated currents
for
1
2
2S,
1
2
161,
1
2
167, and
1
2
receptors as a function of diazepam concentration. The maximal diazepam
potentiation of
1
2
161 and
1
2
167 receptors was
dramatically lower (~7-fold) than that for wild-type
1
2
2S
receptors (Table 2). This result was
surprising, considering that
1
2
161 and
1
2
167
receptors bound BZDs with wild-type affinity (Table 1), and indicates
an uncoupling of high affinity BZD binding from BZD potentiation.
Although the potentiation of
1
2
161 and
1
2
167
receptors was small, it was significant (p < 0.05) at diazepam concentrations above 100 nM compared with
1
2,
1
2
40, or
1
2
113 (Table 2). On normalization of the data to maximal potentiation, a ~6-fold increase in the EC50 for diazepam potentiation was observed in
161- and
167-containing receptors compared with wild-type
receptors (Fig. 4B, inset; Table 2).

View larger version (21K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Diazepam potentiates 1 2 161 and
1 2 167 receptors. A, Trace recordings from cells injected with
chimeric construct 1 2 2S (left), 1 2 161
(middle), and 1 2 167 (right).
Cells were voltage-clamped at 80 mV and perfused with ND96 recording
solution or ND96 with 1 µM GABA or 1 µM
GABA plus diazepam (transition to diazepam-containing solutions:
white arrowheads). Far left, diazepam
concentrations. Cells were washed with ND96 recording solution for
5-20 min between drug applications. Note that wild-type 1 2 2S
subunits show a large potentiation, whereas chimeras show smaller
potentiation even at a high concentration of diazepam (1 µM). B, Oocytes injected with wild-type 1 2 2S
(1:1:10), 1 2 (1:1), and 1 2 (1:1:10) cRNA mixtures were
treated with a range of diazepam concentrations in the presence of GABA
and further analyzed. A potentiation response ratio was determined by
dividing the peak current for 1 2 2S ( ), 1 2 ( ),
1 2 161 ( ), and 1 2 167 ( ) exposed to 1 µM GABA plus diazepam (DZ) by the response
to 1 µM GABA alone. Data were fitted to a curve described
by the equation Y = Min + (Max Min)/{1 + 10[(logEC50 X) · n]}, where Max is the maximal potentiation,
Min is the potentiation at the lowest drug concentration tested,
X is the logarithm of diazepam concentration,
EC50 is the half-maximal potentiation response, and
n is the Hill coefficient. Data points
represent mean potentiation from four or more cells from two or more
batches of oocytes. Error bars, standard deviation. The
parameters from the curve fits are presented in Table 2.
Inset, a plot of the same data after normalizing to the
maximum response for 1 2 2 ( ), 1 2 161 ( ), and
1 2 167 ( ) receptors displays the shift in EC50
value for chimera-containing receptors.
|
|
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 2
Summary of voltage-clamp results
Dose-response data for wild-type and chimeric subunit combinations for
GABA and diazepam potentiation of GABA-mediated CI current in
X. laevis oocytes are tabulated. Two-electrode voltage-clamp and data analysis was performed as described (see Materials and Methods). Mean and standard deviation values for maximum potentiation, EC50 values, and Hill coefficients (nH) were
calculated from dose-response data (Figs. 4b and 5) with the use of
Prism software.
|
|
Because a change in GABA EC50 value could
potentially explain the decrease in BZD potentiation observed, GABA
dose responses were measured. Current amplitudes at 1 µM
(test concentration) and 10 mM GABA (maximal concentration)
for all six
1
2
combinations (data not shown) and GABA
dose-response curves for
1
2
161 and
1
2
167 were similar
to those for wild-type
1
2
2S receptors (Fig.
5, Table 2). These data indicate that the
decrease in diazepam potentiation measured for
1
2
161 and
1
2
167 receptors was not caused by an alteration in
GABA-mediated activation. Interestingly, the GABA
EC50 values for
1
2
2S,
1
2
161,
and
1
2
167 receptors were statistically different than that for
1
2 receptors (p < 0.001, Table 2). The
small change in GABA potency in the triple subunit combinations
compared with
1
2 receptors may be indicative of the presence of
the
2S subunit or domains (see Discussion) and suggests that after
injection of
1
2
subunit combinations into X. laevis
oocytes, a majority of the expressed receptors contain a chimeric
subunit.

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
GABA dose response for chimeras is similar to that
of wild-type 1 2 2 receptors. Oocytes were injected
with 1 2 2 (1:1:10, ), 1 2 (1:1, ), 2 2 (1:1,
), and 1 2 161 (1:1:10, ) cRNA to determine whether
reduced diazepam potentiation of chimeras was due to any shift in GABA
dose-response curves. Data were fitted to a curve described by the
equation Y = Min + (Max Min)/{1 + 10[(logEC50 X) · n]}, where Max is the maximal response, Min is
the response at the lowest drug concentration tested, X
is the logarithm of GABA concentration, EC50 is the
half-maximal response, and n is the Hill coefficient. Dose response for both 1 2 161 and 1 2 167 (not shown,
for clarity) are most similar to that of wild-type 1 2 2.
Data points, mean peak current from four or more cells
from two or more batches of oocytes; error bars,
standard deviation. Parameters determined from the curve fits are
presented in Table 2.
|
|
Equilibrium binding studies.
To gain further insight into
whether the decrease in the allosteric coupling of the GABA and BZD
binding sites was due to an intrinsic property of the
chimera-containing receptors, the ability of GABA to potentiate
[3H]flunitrazepam binding to membrane
homogenates prepared from HEK 293 cells expressing
1
2
2S,
1
2
161, and
1
2
167 receptors was measured. In this
experimental paradigm, only the receptor populations containing a
2S
or chimeric subunit were monitored because
1
2 receptors do not
bind BZDs. Fig. 6 plots the potentiation of specific [3H]flunitrazepam binding of
1
2
2S and
1
2
161 receptors as a function of GABA
concentration. The GABA-mediated potentiation of
[3H]flunitrazepam binding in
1
2
161
receptors was nearly abolished at concentrations of GABA up to 100 µM. Similar results were seen for
1
2
167
receptors. In contrast, GABA potentiated
[3H]flunitrazepam binding of
1
2
2S
receptors with an EC50 value of 1.20 ± 0.15 µM and a maximal potentiation of 1.25 ± 0.05 (Fig. 6). These results suggest that the BZD and GABA binding sites are
uncoupled in
1
2
161 and
1
2
167 receptors and that the uncoupling is due to a property of the chimera-containing receptors. In
addition, these results corroborate the markedly reduced diazepam potentiation observed electrophysiologically.

View larger version (14K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
GABA potentiation of
[3H]flunitrazepam binding on wild-type and chimeric
receptors. GABA potentiation of 2.5 nM
[3H]flunitrazepam binding was measured in membrane
homogenates prepared from HEK 293 cells expressing 1 2 2 ( )
and 1 2 161 ( ) receptors (see Materials and Methods).
Potentiation was calculated by dividing specific dpm in the presence of
GABA by specific dpm in the absence of GABA, and the resulting data
were fit to a single-site sigmoidal dose-response curve (see Materials
and Methods; Fig. 4). Data points, mean potentiation of
binding from eight experiments with 1 2 2 and six experiments
with 1 2 161. Error bars, standard error.
|
|
Further Localization of the BZD Binding Site
By comparing the
/
crossover positions (Fig. 1B) in chimeras
that bound BZDs with high affinity (
161,
167) with those that did
not (
40,
82,
107, and
113), a region of 48 amino acid
residues (R114-D161) of the
2S subunit that is essential for BZD
binding can be identified. This determination requires that
1
2
receptor combinations using
40,
82,
107, or
113 subunits
were assembled and expressed efficiently. To address this question, the
chimeric subunits were individually expressed with
2 subunits in
X. laevis oocytes and the ability of GABA to activate a
Cl
-specific current was tested. Because the
dual subunit combinations
1
2 and
2
2S form functional
GABA-gated receptors when expressed in X. laevis oocytes
(Table 2; Sigel et al., 1990
) and
2 subunits expressed
alone cannot, expression of
2
combinations directly tests the
capability of the chimeras to assemble into functional receptors. We
observed GABA-mediated Cl
currents using all
six
2
subunit combinations (data not shown).
2
40,
2
82,
2
161, and
2
167 had maximal GABA current
amplitudes similar to
2
2S (3
µA). The maximal GABA currents
of
2
107 and
2
113 receptors were ~5-fold smaller.
Interestingly, although diazepam potentiated the GABA response in
2
2S receptors (EC50 = 24 ± 2 nM), diazepam did not potentiate the GABA current of any of
the
2
receptors (see Discussion). Nevertheless, these results
demonstrate that the chimeric subunits can be assembled into functional
2
receptors. If the chimeric subunits assemble into functional
1
2
receptors in a similar manner, a region of 48 amino acids
delimited by
113 to
161 in
2S is required for BZD binding.
To determine whether this region is not only necessary but also
sufficient for BZD binding, a chimeric subunit (
114-161, Fig. 1B)
was constructed that replaced the region from H101 to D148 in the
1
subunit with the homologous
2S region (R114-D161). This chimera,
when expressed with wild-type
1 and
2 subunits, did not
specifically bind [3H]flunitrazepam,
[3H]Ro15-1788, or
[3H]Ro15-4513 at concentrations up to 200 nM (data not shown). To determine whether
114-161 could
assemble into a functional receptor, it was expressed with wild-type
2 subunits, and the binding of [3H]muscimol
was measured. The
114-161
2 receptor specifically bound
[3H]muscimol with a
KD value of 108 ± 30 nM and a Bmax value
of 0.6 ± 0.4 pmol/mg (four experiments). Membrane homogenates
prepared from HEK 293 cells expressing
2 alone did not specifically
bind [3H]muscimol. These data suggest that the
lack of BZD binding by
1
2
114-161 receptors cannot be
explained by an impairment in the assembly or expression of the
114-161 subunit. Therefore, although the R114-D161 region of
2S
may be necessary for BZD binding, it clearly is not sufficient.
Because
114-161 did not bind BZDs, two
/
/
/
chimeras
were constructed (
40/114-161 and
82/114-161; Fig. 1B) that
replaced in both
40 and
82 the
1 region from H101 to D148 with
the homologous
2S region (R114-D161). These chimeras were expressed
with wild-type
1 and
2 subunits in HEK 293 cells and the binding
of [3H]flunitrazepam was measured. The
1
2
40/114-161 receptors did not specifically bind
[3H]flunitrazepam or
[3H]Ro15-4513, whereas
1
2
82/114-161
receptors bound [3H]flunitrazepam in a similar
fashion to
1
2
2S receptors with a
KD of 17.8 ± 5.4 nM and a Bmax of
0.36 ± 0.06 pmol/mg (six experiments) (Fig.
7).
1
2
82/114-161 receptors
showed no significant differences from
1
2
2S receptors in the
KI values for Ro15-1788
(KI = 12.7 ± 3.1 nM, three experiments) or Ro15-4513
(KI = 23.0 ± 9.4 nM, four experiments). Thus, only two regions of
the
2S subunit, Q1-W82 and R114-D161, are required for high affinity
BZD binding. Amino acid sequence comparison of
1
2
40/114-161
receptors, which do not bind BZDs, and
1
2
82/114-161 receptors
suggests that high affinity BZD binding requires only the
2S domains
K41-W82 and R114-D161.

View larger version (26K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7.
  82/114-161 receptors bind
[3H]flunitrazepam. Chimeric subunits were individually
expressed with wild-type 1 and 2 subunits in HEK 293 cells and
the binding of 100 nM [3H]flunitrazepam was
measured (see Materials and Methods). Percentages were calculated by
normalizing specific [3H]flunitrazepam binding of
1 2 receptors to 1 2 2S binding. Results are presented
as mean ± standard error. The number of individual experiments is
shown in parentheses. , 1 2 2S receptors; ,
1 2 40/114-161 receptors; , 1 2 82/114-161
receptors.
|
|
 |
Discussion |
TRCP.
The use of TRCP was successful. By choosing available
restriction sites, we specifically targeted DNA sequence crossovers to
the amino-terminal regions of the
1 and
2S subunits (see Materials and Methods). Moreover, by engineering a sequence with silent
mutations to provide new restriction enzyme sites, one could choose any
region to target for crossover events. Thus, TRCP should prove useful
for any multisubunit protein.
Despite relatively low amino acid identity (Shivers et al.,
1989
), the intersubunit chimeras described in this study (
2S/
1) formed functional channels. Intersubunit chimeras can furnish different
structural/functional information from that furnished by subunit
subtype chimeras (e.g.,
1/
3), such as determining areas that are
unique to each subunit and regions that are interchangeable between
subunits. This was particularly useful because we were interested in
identifying structural determinants of BZD binding and potentiation
that were unique to the ![]()