Neuroscience Program (T.R.N., R.L.M.) and Departments of
Neurology (R.L.M.) and Physiology (R.L.M.), University of Michigan, Ann
Arbor, Michigan
 |
Introduction |
-aminobutyric acid
(GABA) is the major inhibitory
neurotransmitter in the vertebrate brain. Fast inhibitory
postsynaptic potentials are mediated by
GABAA receptors (GABARs), which contain binding
sites for many modulators including benzodiazepines, barbiturates, zinc
and general anesthetics including neurosteroids. GABARs have also been
identified on peripheral neurons and nonneuronal cell types. The
role of GABARs outside the central nervous system (CNS) is not well
documented, but it has been proposed that GABARs may play a role in the
motility of uterine contractions and the secretion of hormones from
endocrine cells.
GABARs are composed of five subunits that together form a transmembrane
chloride ion channel. Four different mammalian subunit families (
,
,
,
) and their subtypes (
1-6,
1-3,
1-3) have been
studied extensively (Macdonald and Olsen, 1994
). Two new subunit
families,
(Davies et al., 1997
) and
(Hedblom and Kirkness, 1997
), have recently been identified. In addition,
,
,
, and
subunit subtypes have been shown to be differentially expressed throughout development (Laurie et al., 1992
) and in different regions
of the rat brain (Wisden et al., 1992
). The developmental expression of
and
subunits has not been reported. Pharmacological studies of
recombinant receptors have shown that individual subunits and their
subtypes confer different sensitivities to such GABAR modulators as
benzodiazepines (Pritchett et al., 1989
; Wieland et al., 1992
) and zinc
(Draguhn et al., 1990
). The subunit composition of the pentamer seems
to be highly regulated and all of the potential subtype combinations do
not assemble to create functional GABARs (Angelotti et al., 1993
;
Burgard et al., 1996
). In addition, receptors composed of 

subunits may be further restricted by a 2:2:1 stoichiometry (Chang et
al., 1996
; Tretter et al., 1997
).
The recently cloned
subunit is most closely related to GABAR
(37%) and
(35%) subunits and to the GABAC
receptor
subunit (33%) and is less similar to other GABAR or
glycine receptor subunits. The
subunit was amplified from the cDNA
libraries of a number of reproductive tissue (uterus, ovaries),
digestive tissue (gall bladder, small intestine), and two brain regions
(hippocampus and temporal cortex) with reverse transcription-polymerase
chain reaction, but no transcripts were hybridized from whole brain samples with Northern analysis (Hedblom and Kirkness, 1997
). In addition, the
subunit is expressed by the teratocarcinoma NT2 neuronal precursor cells (Hedblom and Kirkness, 1997
) and the terminally differentiated NT2-N cells (Neelands et al., 1998
). We have
previously shown that the NT2 neuronal precursor cells also express
high levels of mRNA for the
5 and
3 GABAR subunit subtypes and
low levels of the
3 subtype. GABAR currents in these cells are
highly sensitive to inhibition by zinc, enhanced by loreclezole, and
unaffected by application of the benzodiazepine diazepam (Neelands et
al., 1997
).
There has been some question of whether or not the
subunit
coassembles with other GABAR subunits to form functional GABARs. Human
embryonic kidney 293 fibroblasts transfected with the
subunit alone
or in combination with either an
1 or a
1 subunit did not bind
the GABAR ligands, muscimol, or
t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate and no current was
evoked by application of GABA (Hedblom and Kirkness, 1997
). Muscimol
and t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate did, however,
bind to GABARs composed of the
1
1
combination but was
indistinguishable from binding to
1
1 GABARs (Hedblom and
Kirkness, 1997
). Transfection of cells with higher concentrations of
subunit cDNA than
2 subtype cDNA produced GABARs with reduced binding of the benzodiazepine site ligand flumazenil, which suggests that the
subunit was interfering with the ability of the
subunit to incorporate into functional GABARs (Hedblom and Kirkness,
1997
). However, there is as yet no electrophysiological evidence that the
subunit is incorporated into functional GABARs. The aim of the
present study was to determine whether coexpression of the
subunit
with
and
or
,
, and
subunits produced GABARs with
properties similar to or different from those of 
or 

receptors, consistent with incorporation of the
subunit into GABARs. In addition we wanted to determine whether incorporation of the
subunit altered the pharmacological and biophysical properties of GABARs.
 |
Materials and Methods |
Transfections.
Full-length cDNAs for rat GABAR
5
(obtained from A. Tobin, University of California, Los Angeles),
3
(obtained from D. Pritchett, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia,
PA), and
3 (obtained from P. Seeburg, Max-Planck Institute for
Medical Research, Heidelberg, Germany) subtypes were subcloned into the
pCMVNeo expression vector and human
(obtained from E. Kirkness, The
Institute for Genomic Research, Rockville, MD) was subcloned into the
pCDM8 expression vector. For selection of transfected cells, the
plasmid pHook-1 (Invitrogen, San Diego, CA) containing cDNA encoding
the surface antibody sFv was also transfected into the cells. L929
cells were maintained in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's medium plus 10%
heat-inactivated horse serum, 100 U/ml penicillin and 100 µg/ml
streptomycin (Greenfield et al., 1997
). Cells were passaged by a 5-min
incubation with 0.5% trypsin/0.2% EDTA solution in PBS (10 mM
Na2HPO4, 0.15 mM NaCl, pH
7.3).
Cells from the mouse fibroblast L929 cell line (American Type Culture
Collection, Rockville, MD) were transfected with cDNAs by using a
modified calcium phosphate method (Chen and Okayama, 1987
; Angelotti et
al., 1993
). Plasmids encoding GABAR subtype cDNAs were added to the
cells in 1:1 ratios of 4 µg each plus 2 to 4 µg of the plasmid
encoding sFv. After a 4- to 6-h incubation at 3%
CO2, the cells were treated with a 15% glycerol
solution in buffer (50 mM
N,N-bis[2-hydroxyethyl]-2-aminoethanesulfonic acid, 280 mM NaCl, 1.5 mM
Na2HPO4) for 30 s. The
selection procedure for sFv antibody expression was performed 20 to
28 h later as described previously (Greenfield et al., 1997
).
Briefly, the cells were passaged and mixed with 3 µl of magnetic
beads coated with hapten (approximately 4.5 × 105 beads; Invitrogen). After 30 to 60 min of
incubation to allow the beads to bind to positively transfected cells,
the beads and bead-coated cells were isolated with a magnetic stand.
The selected cells were resuspended into Dulbecco's modified Eagle's
medium, plated onto 35-mm culture dishes, and used for recording 18 to 28 h later.
Recording Solutions and Techniques.
For both whole-cell and
outside-out patch recording, the external solution consisted of 142 mM
NaCl, 8.1 mM KCl, 6 mM MgCl2, 1 mM
CaCl2, 10 mM glucose, and 10 mM HEPES, pH 7.4, and osmolarity adjusted to 295 to 305 mOsM. Recording electrodes were
filled with an internal solution of 153 mM KCl, 1 mM
MgCl2, 5 mM K-EGTA, 10 mM HEPES, and 2 mM MgATP,
pH 7.4, and osmolarity adjusted to 295-305 mOsM. These solutions
provided equilibrium potential for Cl
near 0 mV. Patch pipettes for whole-cell recordings were pulled from either
borosilicate glass (Fisher Scientific, Pittsburgh, PA) or Labcraft
microhematocrit capillary tubes (Curtin Matheson Scientific, Inc.,
Houston TX) on a P-87 Flaming Brown puller (Sutter Instrument Co., San
Rafael, CA) to a resistance of 8-12 M
. For single-channel
recording, patch pipettes were pulled from thick-walled borosilicate
glass with an internal filament (World Precision Instruments, Sarasota,
FL), fire polished to a resistance of 5-10 M
, and coated with
Q-dope (GC Electronics, Rockford, IL) to reduce capacitance.
Loreclezole, (3
)-hydroxy-(5
)-pregnane-11,20-dione (alphaxalone),
and diazepam were first dissolved in 100% dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO)
and then added to external solution in the appropriate volume. The
highest DMSO concentration applied to the cells was 0.3% (v/v) to
prevent direct effects of DMSO on channel activity. All chemicals were
obtained from commercial sources. Loreclezole was a gift from Janssen
Laboratories (Beerse, Belgium). For whole-cell recordings, drugs
were applied to cells with a modified U-tube system with a 10-90 rise
time around 70 ms (Greenfield and Macdonald, 1996
). Although this
application rate is fast, it is too slow to capture the fastest rates
of desensitization (~10 ms). For outside-out patch-clamp recordings,
drugs were applied with a pressure ejection pipette. Currents were
recorded with a List EPC-7 (Darmstadt, Germany) or an Axopatch 1-B
(Axon Instruments, Foster City, CA) patch clamp amplifier, recorded on
hard disk with the Axotape program (Axon Instruments) and stored on VHS or Beta videotape. All experiments were performed at room temperature.
Data Analysis.
Whole-cell currents were analyzed off-line
with the programs Axotape and Prism (Graphpad, San Diego, CA). All
whole-cell current amplitudes were obtained by measuring the peak
current evoked during the application of GABA or GABA plus drug. The
magnitude of the enhancement or inhibition of GABAR current by a drug
was measured by dividing the peak amplitude of GABAR currents elicited in the presence of a given concentration of the drug (with GABA) by the
peak amplitude of control current elicited by GABA alone and
multiplying the fraction by 100 to express it as percent of control.
Thus, the control response was 100%. Peak GABAR currents at various
drug concentrations were fitted to a sigmoidal function with a
four-parameter logistic equation (sigmoidal concentration-response) with a variable slope. The equation used to fit the
concentration-response relationship was:
where I is the GABAR current at a given GABA concentration,
Imax is the maximal GABAR current and
nH is the Hill coefficient. The
curve-fitting algorithm minimized the sum of the squares of the actual
distance of points from the curve. Convergence was reached when two
consecutive iterations changed the sum of the squares by < 0.01%. Data were presented as mean ± S.E.M. All four parameters
were "floating", and therefore, the maximum effect observed was not
necessarily the upper limit of the fit (e.g., see Figs. 2A and 7B). The
only cases in which one of the parameters was not allowed to float were
when inhibitory concentration-response curves did not plateau at the
low end. In these instances, the lower limit was set at zero to prevent
the fitting algorithm from extending into the undefined range below
0%. Figures include the values for the four "floating" parameters:
maximal and minimal values are given on the y-axes, and the
EC50 value and Hill coefficient are given in the
insets. It is important to note that the Hill coefficient does not
represent the number of molecules that bind to the receptor but is only
an indication of the slope of the concentration-response relationship
and is provided throughout the text only to describe the fit. For
compounds that had smaller effects at higher concentrations, the fit
did not include these higher points and were indicated by dashed lines
in the figures. All comparisons of the effect of a compound or voltage
on different subtype combinations were done with GABA
concentrations that produced equivalent responses (extrapolated from
Fig. 1B). Application of GABA was
repeated until the peak currents had stabilized and functioned as
controls for each cell. Coapplication of the same concentration of GABA
with increasing concentrations of individual modulators was performed
to determine the maximal effect and potency of each modulator on
GABARs. All fits were made to average, normalized data with the current
expressed as a percentage of the maximum current elicited by control
GABA concentrations for each cell.

View larger version (20K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
Comparison of GABA concentration-response curves. A,
representative current traces of 0.1, 3, and 100 µM GABA recorded
from L929 cells expressing 5 3, 5 3 3, 5 3 , and
5 3 3 . Horizontal bars, drug application. B, normalized
averaged concentration-response curves for GABA-evoked currents from
the same four subunit combinations. Data are mean ± S.E.M. C,
comparison of EC50 values calculated from
concentration-response curves of individual cells.
(*p < .05; **p < .01).
|
|
To quantify whole-cell current rectification, peak amplitudes of
responses to GABA at equivalent effective concentrations (for example,
EC50) were measured at holding potentials of
75 and +75 mV. These responses exhibited no visible desensitization. An
amplitude ratio (+75 mV/
75 mV) was calculated, and rectification was
determined with respect to a linear ratio equal to 1 with the predicted
ECl equal to 0 mV. An amplitude ratio greater
than 1.0 indicated outward rectification.
Single-channel recordings were digitized with Axoscope and analyzed
with pClamp6 (Axon Instruments). For analysis, the data were digitized
at 20 kHz and filtered at 2 kHz.
Statistical comparisons among GABAR subunit combinations were performed
with one-way ANOVAs with Newman-Keuls posthoc tests to determine which
combinations differed. Post hoc tests were performed only on data sets
in which the p value of the ANOVA was less than 0.05. In
comparisons of individual EC/IC50 values, the log
values of the drug concentration were used for standard parametric
ANOVAs. All statistical tests were performed with the Instat program (Graphpad).
 |
Results |
GABA Sensitivity of Cells Coexpressing
5
3,
5
3
3,
5
3
, and
5
3
3
Subtype Combinations
GABA Concentration-Response Curves.
To determine which
combinations of
5,
3,
3, and
subtypes could assemble in
L929 cells to form functional GABARs, we coexpressed different subtype
combinations in L929 cells and obtained whole-cell recordings and GABA
concentration-response relationships. In parallel transfections, no
GABAR currents were recorded from cells coexpressing
5
3
(n = 5), 
3
3 (n = 5),
5
(n = 5), or
3
(n = 4) subtypes or
the
subunit alone (n = 4). Previous work in our
laboratory has shown that L929 cells do not form functional channels
when cells are cotransfected with 
or 
subunits or
transfected with an
,
, or
subunit alone (Angelotti et al.,
1993
; Saxena and Macdonald, 1994
; Burgard et al., 1996
; Neelands et
al., 1999
). In subsequent experiments, concentration-dependent GABAR
currents were obtained from cells cotransfected with
5
3,
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
subtypes (Fig. 1A). The
amplitudes of currents varied considerably among transfections and
among individual cells, presumably because of differences in
transfection efficiency or cell viability. Given this variability,
there were no apparent differences in the maximum amplitudes of GABAR
currents among the four subunit combinations tested (p = .374).
5
3 currents were larger than previous reports from our
laboratory on 
heterodimers. Whether this was caused by the
subunit combination, the L929 cells used in this study, or some other
factor was not investigated. Complete concentration-response curves
were obtained for the four subunit combinations that were
GABA-sensitive (Fig. 1B) to determine whether the
subunit altered
GABA EC50 values. Peak currents were normalized to the maximum current recorded for each cell. The average maximal currents evoked by GABA were 1002 ± 450, 502 ± 177, 375 ± 103, and 274 ± 96 pA for
5
3,
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
, respectively. Average amplitudes
were normalized to the maximal current evoked for each cell and then
plotted as a function of GABA concentration and fit with a
four-parameter logistic equation (see Materials and
Methods). Cells expressing
5
3 subtypes had an
EC50 value of 0.7 µM
(nH = 1.4; n = 5-13; Fig.
1B). GABA concentration-response curves obtained from cells expressing
5
3 subtypes with either
and/or
3 subtypes were shifted to
the right (Fig. 1B). The EC50 values for the
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
subtype combinations were 1.3 µM (nH, 1.4; n = 4-8), 1.5 µM (nH, 1.6; n = 6-7), and 1.8 µM (nH, 1.8;
n = 6-7), respectively. GABA concentration-response curves for individual cells were also fit with logistic equations and
compared across cells (Fig. 1C). The log EC50
values from the different subunit combinations were significantly
different (one-way ANOVA, p = .030). Post hoc tests
(see Materials and Methods) indicated that the
5
3
subtype GABA EC50 values were significantly different from each of the other subtype combination GABA
EC50 values (p < .05 for
5
3
and
5
3
3 and p < .01 for
5
3
3
subtype combinations). There were no significant
differences among the GABA EC50 values of
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
subtype combinations. In
addition, the normalized current at 1 µM GABA was significantly larger in cells expressing the
5
3 subunit combination than the
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
subtype combinations
(p < .01, p < .01, p < .001, respectively) consistent with the shift in apparent EC50 value. The degree of the rightward shift in
the GABA concentration-response curve (>half a log unit) for
subunit-containing receptors was similar to that previous reported
after coexpression of a
subunit (Angelotti et al., 1993
).
Current-Voltage Relationships.
Current-voltage relations were
generated for the four GABA-sensitive subtype combinations with
EC35 GABA concentrations. Peak currents were
measured at 25-mV increments at holding potentials ranging from
100
to +75 mV (Fig. 2A). Because of the large
variation in maximal current among subunit combinations and differences in expression levels among cells, currents from individual cells were
normalized to the peak current recorded at
75 mV. The average normalized current for each subtype combination was plotted as a
function of the holding potential (Fig. 2B). Currents from the
5
3
subtype combination were outwardly rectifying (Fig. 2A). Average peak
currents evoked at positive potentials were 232 ± 14% (+50 mV)
and 396 ± 33% (+75 mV) of the peak current recorded at
75 mV
(Fig. 2B, inset).
5
3
3 (107 ± 10%, n = 7 at +75 mV) and
5
3
3
(n = 2, data not shown)
subtype currents were both linear over the membrane potentials tested
(Fig. 2B). The normalized current amplitudes for these two subunit
combinations superimposed.
5
3
currents, however, still
displayed outward rectification (209 ± 46% at +75 mV). An ANOVA
performed on the degree of rectification among the
5
3,
5
3
, and
5
3
3 subunit combinations was significant (p < .001). Post hoc tests showed the degree of
rectification was significantly greater for currents from the
5
3
subtype combination compared with currents from
5
3
or
5
3
3 subtype combinations (p < .01 at +75 mV
and p < .001 at +50 mV for both combinations). In
addition, the
5
3
currents had significantly greater
rectification than
5
3
3 currents (p < .05).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Comparison of the current-voltage relations of
GABA-evoked currents. A, representative current traces evoked by
EC35 GABA concentrations at holding potentials of 75 and + 75 mV for 5 3, 5 3 , and 5 3 3 subunit
combinations. The 75 mV current is inverted and superimposed on the + 75 mV trace. Horizontal bars, drug application. B, peak currents at
each potential are normalized to the peak current at 75 mV. Average
normalized currents are plotted on the y-axis against
the membrane holding potential (HP) on the x-axis.
Inset, amplitude ratio of peak currents evoked at +75 and 75 mV. Data
are mean ± S.E.M. Pharmacology of GABAR-evoked currents from
cells coexpressing 5 3, 5 3 3, 5 3 , and
5 3 3 subtypes.
|
|
Pharmacology of GABAR Currents from Cells Coexpressing
5
3,
5
3
3,
5
3
, and
5
3
3
Subtypes
Benzodiazepines.
The effects of benzodiazepine site ligands,
such as diazepam, have been shown to require a
subunit in the GABAR
to exert their effects. To determine whether a
subunit could
replace a
subunit in the formation of the benzodiazepine site we
tested the ability of diazepam (1 µM) to enhance GABAR currents in
cells coexpressing the
subunit with other subtypes (Fig.
3A). Control currents evoked from cells
coexpressing the
5
3
subtypes by 1 µM GABA were not enhanced
by diazepam (n = 4). In parallel transfections, diazepam enhanced
5
3
3 currents to 159 ± 13% of control
(n = 15) but had no effect (105 ± 3%) on
5
3
3
currents (n = 5; Fig. 3B, C). The
differences in current enhancement by diazepam were significantly
different among the subtype combinations tested (p = .012). The magnitude of enhancement of
5
3
3 currents was significantly different (p < .05) from that of
currents from the other two subtype combinations, but there was no
difference between the effect of diazepam on
5
3
3
and
5
3
currents (p > .05).

View larger version (22K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Comparison of the effect of 1 µM diazepam. A,
superimposed current traces of successive applications of 1 µM GABA
(black trace) and 1 µM GABA plus 1 µM diazepam (gray trace) for
5 3 , 5 3 3, and 5 3 3 . Horizontal
bars, drug application. B, average percentage of
modulation of coapplication of 1 µM diazepam. Data are mean ± S.E.M. (*p < .05). C, effects of coapplication of
1 µM diazepam on individual cells expressing 5 3 ,
5 3 3, and 5 3 3 .
|
|
Loreclezole.
The novel anticonvulsant drug loreclezole has
been shown to potentiate GABAR currents when the isoforms contained a
2 or
3 subunit subtype but not a
1 subtype (Wafford et al.,
1994
). Although the degree of potentiation by 1 µM loreclezole varied depending on the isoform, all currents from cells containing subunit combinations that included the
3 subtype were loreclezole-sensitive (Wingrove et al., 1994
). To determine whether coexpression of the
subunit altered loreclezole sensitivity, we determined the concentration-dependence of loreclezole enhancement of currents evoked
by EC60 GABA concentrations from the
5
3,
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
subtype combinations
(Fig. 4A). Coapplication of up to 10 µM
loreclezole caused a concentration-dependent increase of all subtype
combination currents except the
5
3
3 combination (Fig. 4B). The
percentage of enhancement started to decrease with application of
higher loreclezole concentrations, as in previous reports (Donnelly and
Macdonald, 1996
). Interestingly,
5
3
3
and
5
3
currents were enhanced to a similar extent by loreclezole over the
whole range of concentrations tested. The enhancement of loreclezole (3 µM) among subtype combinations was significantly different
(p = .221). Enhancement of current from all three of these subunit combinations was statistically different from the loreclezole effect on the insensitive
5
3
3 currents at 3 µM loreclezole (p < .05).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Modulation of GABA-evoked currents by loreclezole. A,
superimposed current traces of successive applications of
EC60 GABA concentrations (upper trace) and coapplication of
GABA plus 3 µM loreclezole (LOR; bottom trace) are shown for
5 3, 5 3 , 5 3 3, and 5 3 3 . Horizontal
bars, drug application. B, concentration-response relationship of
averaged normalized data for loreclezole modulation of currents evoked
by EC60 GABA for the same subunit combinations. Data are
mean ± S.E.M.
|
|
To our surprise, coapplication of loreclezole produced no enhancement
and only a small inhibition of
5
3
3 currents. We demonstrated previously that
5
3
2L currents were responsive to loreclezole (Burgard et al., 1996
). To confirm that the lack of a loreclezole effect was not caused by loreclezole inactivity, we repeated the experiment with a parallel transfection of
5
3
2L subtypes as a
positive control. During this experiment, cells expressing the
5
3
3 subtype combination (n = 3) were
loreclezole-insensitive and those expressing the
5
3
2L
combination were enhanced in a concentration-dependent manner up to 10 µM loreclezole (390 ± 60% of control, n = 5, data not shown). Previous reports have shown that loreclezole enhanced
currents evoked by coapplication of EC20 GABA
concentrations from isoforms containing either an
5 or a
3
subunit in combination with either a
2 or
3 subunit. Consequently, it did not seem reasonable that the combination of
5
and
3 subtypes would eliminate loreclezole sensitivity. Therefore,
in a separate experiment, GABA concentration-response curves for
5
3
3 currents were sequentially generated in the absence and
presence of loreclezole on individual cells. At low GABA concentrations
1 µM loreclezole produced a small but statistically insignificant
increase in peak current, but at high GABA concentrations, loreclezole
reduced peak currents (Fig. 5B). When
concentration-response curves for loreclezole were then repeated with
only 0.2 µM GABA (~EC10), the ability of
loreclezole to enhance the currents evoked by low GABA concentrations
were more clearly demonstrated. Peak currents were enhanced by 410 ± 100% by coapplication of 10 µM loreclezole with 0.2 µM GABA
(Fig. 5A). Although loreclezole (0.3-30 µM) enhanced GABA-evoked
currents during the application of both drugs, the current tended to
increase in amplitude immediately after the application was terminated.
The degree to which this "rebound" occurred was dependent on the
concentration of loreclezole (Fig. 5A, 30 µM loreclezole trace).

View larger version (30K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5.
Dependence on GABA concentration for the effects of
loreclezole on GABA-evoked currents from the 5 3 3 subunit
combination. A, representative current traces of the concentration
dependent effects of loreclezole (1-30 µM) on currents evoked by 0.2 µM GABA from the 5 3 3 combination. Horizontal bars, drug
application. B, average sequential concentration-response relationships
for GABA alone and GABA plus 1 µM loreclezole normalized to the peak
current evoked by 30 µM GABA alone for the 5 3 3 combination.
Arrows indicate the GABA concentration used in Figs. 4A and 5A,
respectively. Data are mean ± S.E.M.
|
|
Barbiturates.
The barbiturate pentobarbital has been shown to
potentiate GABAR currents, directly activate a chloride current, and
act as an open channel blocker at high concentrations (Schulz and
Macdonald, 1981
; Schwartz et al., 1986
; Peters et al., 1988
; Robertson,
1989
; Thompson et al., 1996
). We investigated the effect of
coexpression of the
subunit with
5
3 or
5
3
3 subtypes
on the modulatory actions of pentobarbital. Coapplication of
pentobarbital (0.3-100 µM) with equally effective concentrations of
GABA were used to determine the EC50 value of
pentobarbital for enhancement of
5
3,
5
3
3, and
5
3
currents. Higher concentrations of pentobarbital were not
used because of the direct effects of pentobarbital on GABARs (Fig.
6A). All three subtype combination
currents were enhanced in a concentration-dependent manner by
pentobarbital. Averaged normalized data were fit with a logistic
equation with apparent EC50 values of 25.9 µM
(nH = 1.8, n = 3-5), 39.0 µM (nH = 1.2, n = 4), and
59.5 µM (nH = 1.1, n = 4)
for
5
3,
5
3
3, and
5
3
currents, respectively
(Fig. 6B). There were no statistical differences between the three
subunit combinations when individual EC50 values
were compared (p > .05). The concentration range
tested did not produce a plateau in the effect of pentobarbital at high concentrations. Therefore, fits were allowed to extend beyond the
enhancement of 100 µM pentobarbital (see Materials and
Methods) that resulted in maximal "effects" of 501%
(
5
3), 373% (
5
3
), and 356% (
5
3
3). The effect
of the highest concentration of pentobarbital tested (100 µM) ranged
from 467 ± 130% of control for the
5
3 currents to 307 ± 59% for
5
3
and 265 ± 61% for
5
3
3 currents
but were not statistically different (p > .05; Fig.
6B).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 6.
Enhancement of GABA-evoked currents by pentobarbital.
A, superimposed current traces of successive applications of
EC60 concentrations of GABA (upper trace), GABA plus 30 µM pentobarbital (PB; middle trace), and GABA plus 100 µM
pentobarbital (lower trace) for 5 3, 5 3 , and 5 3 3
subunit combinations. Horizontal bars, drug application. B,
concentration-response relationship of averaged normalized data for
pentobarbital enhancement of currents evoked by EC60 GABA
for the same combinations. Data are mean ± S.E.M.
|
|
Neurosteroids.
Neurosteroids have been shown to have both
positive (alphaxalone) and negative [pregnenolone sulfate (PS)]
allosteric effects on recombinant GABARs. To determine whether the
subunit altered the effects of either of these compounds,
concentration-response curves were generated with EC equivalent
concentrations of GABA in cells expressing either the
5
3,
5
3
, or
5
3
3 subtype combinations.
Alphalxalone potentiated currents evoked by EC60
GABA concentrations for all three subtype combinations tested (Fig.
7A). Averaged normalized currents were
plotted as a function of alphaxalone concentration and fit with a
logistic equation with EC50 values of 342 µM
(nH = 1.5, n = 4), 292 µM
(nH = 2.0, n = 7) and 217 µM (nH = 1.9, n = 8) for
5
3,
5
3
, and
5
3
3 currents, respectively (Fig.
7B). The maximal effect of alphaxalone, measured at 3 µM, was
significantly different among subtype combinations (p = .012). Alphaxalone enhancement of GABAR currents was greater for
5
3 (327 ± 20%) and
5
3
(314 ± 25%)
combinations than for the
5
3
3 combination (193 ± 27%;
p < .01) but were not significantly different from
each other (p > .05; Fig. 7B).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 7.
Enhancement of GABA-evoked currents by alphaxalone.
A, superimposed current traces of successive applications of
EC60 concentrations of GABA (upper trace) and GABA plus 10 µM alphaxalone (ALX; lower trace) for 5 3, 5 3 , and
5 3 3 subunit combinations. Horizontal bars, drug application.
B, concentration-response relationship of averaged normalized data for
pentobarbital enhancement of currents evoked by EC60 GABA
for the same combinations. EC50 value for alphaxalone
enhancement (1 nM-3 µM alphaxalone) was derived independent of the
apparent inhibition seen at higher concentrations (hatched line). Data
are mean ± S.E.M.
|
|
PS inhibited currents evoked by EC80 GABA
concentrations for all three subtype combinations tested (Fig.
8A). Averaged normalized currents were
plotted as a function of PS concentration (10 nM-30 µM). Solubility
of PS in DMSO prevented testing of concentrations higher than 30 µM.
Logistic equations were fit to the data with IC50
values of 12.9 µM (nH =
0.5,
n = 2-4), 1.8 µM (nH =
0.7, n = 3-4), and 0.7 µM
(nH =
0.6, n = 3) for
5
3,
5
3
3, and
5
3
currents, respectively (Fig.
8B). Comparison of the fits for data from individual cells did not
produce significant differences in the apparent
IC50 values between any pair of the subtype
combinations. However, at 3 to 30 µM PS there was a difference in the
percentage inhibition between the subtype combinations
(p < .05).
5
3
and
5
3
3 currents were
inhibited to a greater degree than
5
3 currents (p < .05 and p <0.01, respectively). The inhibition produced
by the highest concentration of PS tested (30 µM) however, was only greater for
5
3
3 currents (16 ± 5% of control) compared
with
5
3 currents (39 ± 5% of control; p < .01; Fig. 8B). These differences in "maximal" effect were probably
caused by the small shift in apparent IC50
values, rather than a change in efficacy of PS for the different
subunit combinations, and were caused by our being unable to use higher
PS concentrations.

View larger version (22K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 8.
Inhibition of GABA-evoked currents by PS. A,
superimposed current traces of successive applications of
EC80 concentrations of GABA (lower trace), GABA plus 3 µM
PS (middle trace), and GABA plus 30 µM PS (upper trace) for 5 3,
5 3 , and 5 3 3 subunit combinations. Horizontal bars,
drug application. B, concentration-response relationship of averaged
normalized data for PS inhibition of currents evoked by
EC80 GABA for the same combinations. Data are mean ± S.E.M.
|
|
Zinc.
The divalent cation zinc inhibited 
and


isoform currents with low IC50 values
(<5 µM), 

isoforms with moderate IC50 values (22-42 µM), and 

isoform currents with high
IC50 values (>100 µM; Draguhn et al., 1990
;
Saxena and Macdonald, 1994
; Whiting et al., 1997
). To determine the
effect the
subunit on the sensitivity of GABAR currents to zinc, we
obtained inhibition curves for zinc for the
5
3,
5
3
3,
5
3
, and
5
3
3
subtype combinations. Zinc (100 nM-1
mM) inhibited currents evoked by EC80 GABA
concentrations for all of the subtype combinations tested (Fig.
9A). Averaged normalized currents were
plotted as a function of zinc concentration and fit with logistic
equations with IC50 values of 2.1 µM
(nH =
0.8, n = 6), 2.4 µM (nH =
0.9, n = 6),
43.3 µM (nH =
0.5, n = 4), and 67.3 µM (nH =
0.6,
n = 5) for
5
3,
5
3
,
5
3
3, and
5
3
3
currents, respectively (Fig. 9B). When comparing
IC50 values obtained from individual cells, the
IC50 values for zinc inhibition were
statistically different (p < .0001). However, IC50 values for zinc inhibition of
5
3 and
5
3
currents or
5
3
3 and
5
3
3
currents were
not significantly different from one another. The individual
IC50 values for zinc inhibition of
5
3 and
5
3
currents were statistically different from inhibition of
both
5
3
3 and
5
3
3
(p < .0001). The
increase in the zinc IC50 for
-containing
subunit combinations was consistent with previous reports (Draguhn et
al., 1990
) but was of smaller magnitude, possibly because of the
expression of the
3 subtype rather than the
2 subtype (used in
most recombinant studies of GABAR pharmacology).

View larger version (35K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 9.
Inhibition of GABA-evoked currents by zinc. A,
superimposed current traces of successive applications of
EC80 concentrations of GABA (lower trace), GABA plus 1 µM
zinc (middle trace), and GABA plus 30 µM zinc (upper trace) for
5 3, 5 3 , 5 3 3, and 5 3 3 subunit
combinations. Horizontal bars, drug application. B,
concentration-response relationship of averaged normalized data for
zinc inhibition of currents evoked by EC80 GABA for the
same combinations. Data are mean ± S.E.M.
|
|
Lanthanum.
The trivalent cation lanthanum inhibited
6
subtype-containing receptor currents but enhanced
1
subtype-containing receptor currents (Saxena et al., 1997
), but the
effects of lanthanum on
5 subtype-containing receptor currents have
not been reported. To determine the effects of
and
5 subunits on
the sensitivity of GABARs to lanthanum we obtained
concentration-response curves for lanthanum for the
5
3,
5
3
3, and
5
3
subtype combinations. Lanthanum inhibited
currents evoked by EC60 GABA concentrations for
all of the combinations tested (Fig.
10A). Averaged normalized currents were
plotted as a function of lanthanum concentration and fit with logistic
equations with IC50 values of 297 µM
(nH =
1.1, n = 4), 540 µM (nH =
1.1, n = 5),
and 522 µM (nH =
0.9, n = 5) for
5
3,
5
3
, and
5
3
3 currents, respectively
(Fig. 10B). When comparing IC50 values obtained
from individual cells, there was a significant difference between
subunit combinations (p = .0051). Lanthanum inhibited
5
3 currents with a significantly lower IC50
value than either
5
3
3 or
5
3
currents
(p < .05, p < .01, respectively). In
addition, the percentage inhibition produced by a high concentration of
lanthanum (1 mM) was different among subunit combinations
(p = .0042). Lanthanum (1 mM) significantly inhibited
5
3 currents (82.0 ± 3.5%) more than either
5
3
(70.2 ± 3.2%) or
5
3
3 (66.9 ± 3.9%) currents
(p < .05, p < .01, respectively). Similar to the inhibition by PS, this difference in "maximal" effect was most likely caused by the shift in the apparent
IC50 value and not to a change in efficacy.