Department of Medicinal Chemistry and Molecular Pharmacology,
Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana (G.H.H., N.D.); and
Department of Pharmacology, University of Washington, Seattle,
Washington (T.S., W.A.C.)
 |
Introduction |
L-type
voltage-gated Ca2+ channels play a critical role
in the initiation of muscle contraction in the cardiovascular system and also contribute to the timing of the cardiac action potential (Bers
and Perez-Reyes, 1999
). Therefore, drugs that inhibit
Ca2+ flux through L-type
Ca2+ channels are used to treat hypertension,
angina pectoris, and some cardiac arrhythmias. Three major classes of
Ca2+ channel blockers are currently in clinical
use: dihydropyridines (DHP), phenylalkylamines (PA), and
benzothiazepines (BZP). Ca2+ channels are
composed of a large, pore-forming
1 subunit
consisting of four homologous domains (I-IV), each containing six
transmembrane segments (S1-S6), in a complex with auxiliary
,
,
and
2
subunits (Takahashi et al., 1987
;
Tanabe et al., 1987
; Catterall, 1995
). L-type
Ca2+ channels in the heart and vascular smooth
muscle contain
1c subunits, which are highly
sensitive to Ca2+ channel blocking drugs, whereas
the drug-insensitive N-type and P/Q-type Ca2+
channels contain
1B and
1A subunits, respectively (reviewed in Hofmann
et al., 1999
).
Drugs from all three of these classes bind to L-type
Ca2+ channels, and their binding sites are
closely linked but not identical (Gould et al., 1983
). Biochemical
experiments utilizing photoreactive derivatives of DHPs and PAs
indicated interaction of DHPs with domains IIIS6 and IVS6 (Nakayama et
al., 1991
; Striessnig et al., 1991
), and PAs with domain IVS6 of the
1 subunit (Striessnig et al., 1990
).
Subsequent experiments using site-directed mutagenesis and
electrophysiological recordings of recombinant channels expressed in
various cell types have led to a detailed picture of the amino acid
residues required for modulation of L-type Ca2+
channels by DHPs and PAs (Hockerman et al., 1997b
; Mitterdorfer et al.,
1998
; Hofmann et al., 1999
).
The site of action for BZPs has been less extensively characterized.
Diltiazem, a clinically relevant member of the BZP class of drugs, has
several unique properties that suggest that its binding site is
distinct from that of DHPs or PAs. Diltiazem stimulates the binding of
DHPs but inhibits the binding of PAs to L-type Ca2+ channels (DePover et al., 1982
; Ferry and
Glossmann, 1982
) suggesting that there are elements of the DHP binding
site that are distinct from the BZP binding site. In addition, block of
L-type Ca2+ channels by diltiazem is
frequency-dependent, similar to but less pronounced than the
frequency-dependent block by PAs (Lee and Tsien, 1983
). This suggests
that both diltiazem and PAs bind preferentially to the open and/or
inactivated states of the channel, and may therefore share some common
binding determinants within the channel. Finally, diltiazem shows lower
selectivity for L-type versus non-L-type Ca2+
channels than DHPs or PAs (Diochot et al., 1995
; Ishibashi et al.,
1995
). This suggests that many of the binding determinants for
diltiazem are identical across Ca2+ channel
types, or that differences at these positions are conservative enough
to allow diltiazem binding.
Biochemical experiments using a photoreactive BZP reported
derivatization of transmembrane segments IIIS6 and IVS6 of L-type Ca2+ channels (Kraus et al., 1996
). Subsequent
studies using chimeric Ca2+ channels with IIIS6
and IVS6 segments from
1C spliced into an
1A background found that many of the same
amino acid residues critical for high affinity PA block (Hockerman et
al., 1995
, 1997a
) were also involved in diltiazem block (Hering et al.,
1996
; Kraus et al., 1998
). To date, no studies have systematically
examined the role of each amino acid residue in the IIIS6 and IVS6
segments. Therefore, we have constructed single amino acid mutations to alanine along the entire IIIS6 and IVS6 segments of
1C and have analyzed each mutant for
sensitivity to block by diltiazem. In addition, we have measured the
sensitivity to diltiazem block of both the wild-type
1A (P/Q-type) channel and an
1A mutant (
1A/DHPS)
that contains the DHP binding site. To assess the contribution to
diltiazem block of amino acid residues in transmembrane domain IIIS5
known to be critical for DHP block (Grabner et al., 1996
; He et al.,
1997
), we have constructed a double amino-acid mutation in IIIS5
(
1C/DHPI) and analyzed it for sensitivity to
both the DHP PN200-110 and diltiazem. Our results reveal several amino acid residues that contribute to block by diltiazem but not by DHPs
and/or PAs; conversely, several key amino acid residues contribute to
block by DHPs and/or PAs but do not contribute to block by diltiazem.
 |
Experimental Procedures |
Construction of Mutants.
Single amino acid mutations in
domains IIIS6 and IVS6 of the
1C subunit
(Snutch et al., 1991
) were constructed using oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis, as described previously (Kunkel, 1985
). The IIIS6 mutations were inserted into full-length subunit constructs in the
expression vector Zem 229 (Dr. Eileen Mulvihill, University of
Washington, Seattle, WA) using the 1.5-kilobase
SpeI/DraIII fragment and the 272 bp
DraIII/DraIII fragment in a three-way ligation.
Construction of the
1A/DHPS mutant was
described previously (Hockerman et al., 1997c
). The
1C/DHPI mutant contains two mutations in
domain IIIS5 (T1039 to Y and Q1043 to M) and was constructed using the
splice overlap extension method (Horton et al., 1989
). The mutant
600-bp DNA fragment was cut with SpeI and BglII
and inserted into the full-length subunit construct in the expression vector Zem 229 using the 900-bp BglII//DraIII
fragment and the 272-bp DraIII/DraIII fragment in
a four-way ligation. All mutations were confirmed by cDNA sequencing.
Cell Culture.
tsA201 cells, a subclone of the human
embryonic kidney cell line 293 that expresses simian virus 40 T antigen
(a gift of Dr. Robert Dubridge, Cell Genesis, Foster City, CA) were
maintained in monolayer culture in Dulbecco's modified Eagle's
medium/Ham's F-12 medium (Life Technologies, Inc., Gaithersburg, MD),
supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (Hyclone, Logan, UT), and
incubated at 37°C in 10% CO2.
Expression.
Wild-type and mutant
1C
channel subunits (Snutch et al., 1991
) were expressed with
1B (Pragnell et al., 1991
) and
2
channel (Ellis et al., 1988
) subunits and
either CD8 antigen (EBO-pCD-Leu2, American Type Culture Collection,
Manassas, VA) or enhanced green fluorescent protein (CLONTECH, Palo
Alto, CA) in tsA201 cells by transfection with either
Ca2+ phosphate (Margolskee et al., 1993
) or the
transfection reagent GenePorter (Gene Therapy Systems, San Diego, CA).
Transfectants were selected by labeling with anti-CD8 antibodies
conjugated to polystyrene beads (Dynal, Oslo, Norway) or by
fluorescence at 510 nm with excitation at 480 nm (enhanced green
fluorescent protein transfected cells).
Electrophysiology.
Ba2+ currents
through Ca2+ channels were measured using the
whole-cell, patch-clamp configuration. Pipettes were pulled from VWR micropipettes (VWR, West Chester, PA) and fire polished to produce an
inner tip diameter of 4 to 6 µm. Currents were recorded using an Axon
Instruments Axopatch 200B amplifier and filtered at 1 or 2 kHz
(six-pole Bessel filter,
3 dB). Voltage pulses were applied and data
were acquired using pClamp6 software (Axon Instruments, Foster City,
CA). Voltage-dependent currents have been corrected for leak using an
online P/
4 subtraction paradigm. (+)-cis-Diltiazem (RBI,
Natick, MA) dissolved in bath saline was applied to cells under voltage
clamp using a fast perfusion system with constant exchange of the bath
solution. PN200-110 was added to the bath without background perfusion
as a 3× stock. The bath saline contained 150 mM Tris, 10 mM
BaCl2, and 4 mM MgCl2. The
intracellular solution contained 130 mM
N-methyl-D-glucamine, 10 mM EGTA, 60 mM HEPES, 2 mM MgATP, 1 mM MgCl2. The pH of both
solutions was adjusted to 7.3 with methanesulfonic acid. All
experiments were done at room temperature (20-23°C).
 |
Results |
Block of Ca2+ Channels Containing Wild-Type
1C and
1A Subunits by
(+)-cis-Diltiazem.
The
1C
subunit (Snutch et al., 1991
) was expressed in tsA201 cells along with
the
1B (Pragnell et al., 1991
) and
2
(Ellis et al., 1988
) subunits.
Ba2+ currents through the resulting L-type
channels were blocked by (+)-cis-diltiazem with an
IC50 value of 33.3 ± 4.6 µM (Fig.
1A, F). For L-type channels, a holding
potential of
60 mV with a 100-ms test pulse to +10 mV at a frequency
of 0.05 Hz was used. Under these conditions, block developed rapidly,
and reached equilibrium within 200 s (Fig. 1B). Little (<10%)
frequency-dependent block accumulated using this low stimulation
frequency. These conditions were used for the assay of diltiazem
sensitivity of all the
1C mutants.

View larger version (24K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 1.
Diltiazem block of wild-type 1C,
1A, 1C/DHPI, and 1A/DHPS.
A, representative Ba2+ current records from a tsA201 cell
expressing wild-type 1C in the absence (control) or
presence of the indicated concentrations of diltiazem. B, time course
of diltiazem block of 1C Ba2+ current
expressed in a tsA201 cell. (+)-cis-diltiazem was
applied at the pulse number and concentrations indicated. Pulses were
to +10 mV from a holding potential of 60 mV every 20 s. C,
Representative current records from a tsA 201 cell expressing wild-type
1A in the absence (control) or presence of the indicated
concentrations of diltiazem. D, representative current records from a
tsA201 cell expressing the mutant 1A/DHPS in the absence
(control) or presence of the indicated concentrations of diltiazem. E,
time course of block of wild-type 1C ( ) and
1C/DHPI ( ) by the DHP PN200-110 (10 µM). F,
summary of the IC50 values of wild-type 1C,
wild-type 1A, 1A/DHPS, and
1C/DHPI for (+)-cis-diltiazem. The
IC50 values (shown ± S.E.) were determined as
described in the legend to Fig. 2. The asterisks denote that the
IC50 values for 1C, 1A/DHPS,
and 1C/DHPI are significantly different from the
IC50 value for 1A (Student's
t test, * P < .05, **
P < .01). Note that 1C/DHPI has the
same sensitivity to diltiazem as wild type 1C even
though it is virtually insensitive to PN200-110.
|
|
In addition to the L-type Ca2+ channel containing
wild-type
1C, we also measured the
concentration dependence of diltiazem block of the P/Q-type
Ca2+ channel containing wild-type
1A (Stea et al., 1994
). These channels have
been reported to be blocked by 2- to 10-fold higher concentrations of
diltiazem than those required to block L-type
Ca2+ channels (Diochot et al., 1995
; Ishibashi et
al., 1995
). We expressed the
1A subunit along
with the
1B and
2
subunits in tsA201 cells and applied increasing concentrations of
(+)-cis-diltiazem to cells under voltage clamp using a
holding potential of
80 mV and 100-ms test pulses to 0 mV at a
frequency of 0.033 Hz. A more negative holding potential (
80 mV) was
used for
1A because the fraction of
inactivated channels at this holding potential is similar to that of
1C at
60 mV (Hockerman et al., 1997c
). The
lower frequency of stimulation was used to prevent accumulation of
inactivated channels. We found that the wild-type
1A channel was blocked by diltiazem under
these conditions with an IC50 value of 169 ± 10 µM, only five times the IC50 value for
wild-type
1C (Fig. 1C, F).
Block of Mutant Ca2+ Channels Containing
1A/DHPS and
1C/DHPI by
(+)-cis-Diltiazem.
We hypothesized that the
difference in sensitivity to diltiazem block between the wild-type
1C and
1A channels
might be caused by changes in relatively few amino acid residues. As an initial experiment, we tested the diltiazem affinity of a mutant
1A channel in which nine amino acids from
1C had been substituted. These substitutions
had been shown previously to confer nearly full sensitivity to DHPs
(Hockerman et al., 1997c
). We expressed this mutant,
1A/DHPS, along with the
1B and
2
subunits
in tsA201 cells and applied increasing concentrations of
(+)-cis-diltiazem to cells under voltage clamp using a
holding potential of
120 mV and 100-ms test pulses to 0 mV at a
frequency of 0.033 Hz. The strongly negative holding potential was
necessary to compensate for the very negative voltage dependence of
inactivation of the
1A/DHPS mutant (Hockerman
et al., 1997c
). Diltiazem blocked Ba2+ currents
through
1A/DHPS with an
IC50 value of 35.5 ± 13.6 µM, a
concentration virtually identical with that of wild-type
1C (Fig. 1, D and F).
The nine L-type specific amino acids substituted
in
1A/DHPS are in domains IIIS5, IIIS6, and
IVS6 of
1A. Amino acid residues in
transmembrane segments IIIS6 and IVS6 had been previously implicated in
diltiazem block (Kraus et al., 1996
), so we focused on segment IIIS5.
1A/DHPS contains substitutions of two
L-type-specific amino acid residues in IIIS5. We made a mutant L-type
channel,
1C/DHPI, containing the converse
changes by substituting T1039 with Y and Q1043 with M in domain IIIS5
of
1C. Mutation of these amino acids
dramatically decreases DHP affinity for
1C
(Mitterdorfer et al., 1996
; He et al., 1997
). We expressed the
1C/DHPI mutant channel in tsA201 cells along
with the
1B and
2
subunits and added increasing concentrations of
(+)-cis-diltiazem to cells under voltage clamp using a
holding potential of
60 mV and test pulses to +10 mV for 100 ms at
0.05 Hz. The wild-type
1C and
1C/DHPI could be compared at the same holding
potential because their V1/2 values for
inactivation are not significantly different (data not shown). Although
Ba2+ currents through the resulting channels were
not blocked by PN200-110 at 10 µM (Fig. 1E), the
IC50 value for diltiazem was not different from
wild-type
1C (Fig. 1F). Thus, T1039 and Q1043
are critical for DHP block but unnecessary for diltiazem block of
1C.
Effects of Single Amino Acid Alanine Substitution Mutants in
Transmembrane Segment IIIS6 on Block by
(+)-cis-Diltiazem.
Because photoaffinity labeling
studies suggest that diltiazem interacts with both transmembrane
domains IIIS6 and IVS6 (Kraus et al., 1996
), we screened a battery of
single amino acid mutations to alanine spanning both the IIIS6 and IVS6
transmembrane domains of
1C for
concentration-dependent block by diltiazem. At positions where the
native amino acid is alanine, we substituted the corresponding amino
acid in non-L-type channels (A1157P, A1467S). We also made more
conservative changes at tyrosines 1152 and 1463, mutating them to
phenylalanine. We expressed the
1C mutant
channels in tsA201 cells along with the
1B and
2
subunits and added increasing concentrations of (+)-cis-diltiazem to cells under voltage
clamp using a holding potential of
60 mV and test pulses to +10 mV for 100 ms at 0.05 Hz. Of the single amino acid mutations tested, only
A1157P did not express current. The functional properties of the mutant
channels that were expressed at low level have been described
previously (Hockerman et al., 1997a
). Of the 21 single amino acid
mutants in segment IIIS6 that we screened, eight had no significant
change in diltiazem affinity, and six had <2-fold change in the
IC50 value for diltiazem (Fig.
2). In contrast, mutants I1150A, I1153A,
I1156A, and M1160A in the central portion of the segment had
substantially reduced sensitivity to diltiazem block compared with
wild-type
1C (I1150A,
IC50 = 97.1 ± 20.6 µM; I1153A,
IC50 = 93.1 ± 24.4 µM; I1156A,
IC50 = 83.6 ± 10.9 µM; M1160A,
IC50 = 107.9 ± 7.7 µM). In addition,
mutation of two amino acid residues near the intracellular end of this
transmembrane segment, F1164A and V1165A, also resulted in
substantially decreased potency of diltiazem block of
Ba2+ current (F1164A, IC50 = 90.8 ± 9.4 µM; V1165A, IC50 = 131 ± 40 µM).

View larger version (29K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 2.
Diltiazem block of wild-type 1C
channels and 1C channels with single-amino-acid
mutations in IIIS6. A, L-type Ba2+ currents were recorded
from wild-type and mutant 1C L-type channels as
described under Experimental Procedures. Representative
traces are shown in the absence (control) or presence of the indicated
concentrations of (+)-cis-diltiazem for wild-type amino
acids (left), the mutant I1150A (center), and the mutant M1160A
(right). B, dose-response relationships for the indicated wild type and
mutant channels. In each case, the averaged, normalized current
amplitudes at 5, 10, 50, 100, and 500 µM diltiazem (symbols ± S.E.) were plotted against the corresponding drug concentration, and
the IC50 value was determined by fitting the averaged
relative current values at each diltiazem concentration to the
equation, relative current = 1
{1/[1+(IC50/[diltiazem])]} (smooth lines). C, the
IC50 values of the indicated mutations in IIIS6 for
diltiazem are shown ± S.E. Asterisks denote that the
IC50 value for diltiazem of the indicated mutant channel is
significantly different from that of wild-type 1C
(Student's t test: * P < .05, **
P < .01, *** P < .001).
|
|
Effects of Block of Single-Amino-Acid Alanine Substitution Mutants
in Transmembrane Segment IVS6 by (+)-cis-Diltiazem.
We also screened single-amino-acid mutations across transmembrane IVS6
for concentration dependence of diltiazem block as described above. The
functional properties of these mutant Ca2+
channels have been described previously (Hockerman et al., 1995
). Of
the 13 amino acids in IVS6 that were mutated, only mutant channels I1460A, Y1463F, and M1464A showed decreased sensitivity to diltiazem (I1460A, IC50 = 69.5 ± 7.5 µM; Y1463F,
IC50 = 114.4 ± 19 µM; M1464A, IC50 = 91.8 ± 8.9 µM; Fig.
3).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 3.
Diltiazem block of wild-type 1C
channels and 1C channels with single-amino-acid
mutations in IVS6. A, L-type Ba2+ currents were recorded
from wild-type and mutant 1C L-type channels as
described under Experimental Procedures. A,
representative traces are shown in the absence (control) or presence of
the indicated concentrations of (+)-cis-diltiazem for
wild-type (left), the mutant I1460A (center), and the mutant M1464A
(right). B, dose-response relationships are shown for the indicated
wild-type and mutant channels and are as described in the legend to
Fig. 2. C, the IC50 values of the indicated mutations in
IVS6 for diltiazem are shown ± S.E. and were determined as
described in the legend to Fig. 2. An asterisk denotes that the
IC50 value for diltiazem of the indicated mutant channel is
significantly different from that of wild-type 1C
(Student's t test, * P < .05, ***
P < .001).
|
|
Because diltiazem binds with higher affinity to L-type channels in the
inactivated state, we measured the effect of the single-amino-acid mutations found to decrease diltiazem sensitivity on the
voltage-dependence of inactivation. In IVS6, I1460A
(V1/2 =
18.2 mV), and Y1463F (V1/2=
19.2 mV), both of which
significantly decreased potency of diltiazem block, were not different
from wild-type
1C
(V1/2 =
17.0 mV), whereas M1464A
(V1/2 =
13.5 mV) was only slightly
positively shifted compared with wild-type. In IIIS6, I1150A
(V1/2=
13.0 mV), I1153A
(V1/2=
12 mV), and V1165A
(V1/2=
14.5 mV) were also slightly
shifted from wild-type
1C, whereas I1156A
(V1/2=
10.0 mV) and F1164A
(V1/2=
9.1 mV) had greater positive
shifts in voltage dependence of inactivation. Nevertheless, the holding potential used in our experiments (
60 mV) is sufficiently negative to
prevent inactivation of either wild-type
1C or
mutant channels, so that positive shifts in
V1/2 will not result in a smaller fraction of inactivated channels. Therefore, the reduced sensitivity of the
mutant channels to diltiazem is most likely caused by changes in drug
affinity and not by changes in inactivation properties.
In addition to the single amino acid mutations, we also examined the
effect of a triple mutation in IVS6 (YAI, Y1463I+A1467S+I1470A) that
had previously been shown to greatly decrease block by the high-affinity phenylalkylamine (
)-D888 (Hockerman et al., 1995
). Transfer of the L-type amino acids to the corresponding positions in
IVS6 of the
1A subunit has been shown to
increase the sensitivity of P/Q-type Ca2+
channels to diltiazem (Hering et al., 1996
). We found that the YAI
mutant is less sensitive to diltiazem than wild-type
1C (IC50 = 134.5 ± 13.8 µM), but only to an extent similar to the much more conservative
mutation Y1463F (Fig. 3). Furthermore, we found no appreciable increase
in the IC50 value of diltiazem for the single-amino-acid mutants A1467S and I1470A.
 |
Discussion |
Distinct but Overlapping Binding Sites for BZPs and DHPs on
1C.
Using the
1A/DHPS
channel, we have shown that insertion of a DHP binding site into a
channel that is normally insensitive to DHP increases the sensitivity
to block by diltiazem by 5-fold, making the IC50
value of diltiazem for this mutant
1A channel virtually identical with the wild-type
1C
(Fig. 1, D and F). Because
1A/DHPS contains
amino acid substitutions in three transmembrane segments, IIIS5, IIIS6,
and IVS6, we assessed the contribution of amino acid residues in these
three regions to diltiazem block. Mutation of both T1039 and Q1043 in
IIIS5 of
1C (mutant
1C/DHPI), removes DHP block (Mitterdorfer et
al., 1996
; He et al., 1997
) (Fig. 1E) and virtually eliminates DHP
binding (He et al., 1997
), but does not affect block by diltiazem (Fig.
1F). Therefore, T1039 and Q1043 in IIIS5 are clearly involved in DHP
block, but not diltiazem block, of
1C.
Similarly, Y1152, F1158, F1159, and M1161 in transmembrane segment
IIIS6 as well as I1470, I1471, and N1472 in segment IVS6 are required
for DHP binding and block but not for BZP block (Fig.
4). Thus, nine amino acid residues in
these three transmembrane segments are involved in the DHP receptor site but not the BZP receptor site.

View larger version (47K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 4.
Amino acid residues required for binding of calcium
antagonist drugs. Top, amino acid sequences of transmembrane segments
IIIS5, IIIS6, and IVS6 of 1A, 1C, and
1A/DHPS. Amino acid residues in bold type are required
for high-affinity BZP binding. Amino acid residues in bold italic type
are required for high-affinity BZP binding, but not included in
1A/DHPS. Bottom, transmembrane -helical segments,
with amino acid residues required for high-affinity binding of DHPs,
BZPs, and PAs indicated as .
|
|
Other amino acid residues in transmembrane segments IIIS6 and IVS6 are
required for BZP block but not for block by DHPs (Fig. 4). I1150,
F1164, and V1165 in segment IIIS6 and I1460 in segment IVS6 are
important for BZP block but not for DHP binding and block. These
results also support the conclusion that the BZP and DHP sites are separate.
In contrast, four amino acid residues in segments IIIS6 and IVS6
contribute to DHP binding and block and to BZP block (Fig. 4). Y1463
and M1464 in segment IVS6 as well as I1153 and I1156 in segment IIIS6
all contribute to DHP action (Peterson et al., 1997
). These residues
were included in
1A/DHPS and two other similar
chimeric mutants resulting in gain of DHP binding and modulation
(Hockerman et al., 1997c
; Ito et al., 1997
; Sinnegger et al., 1997
).
These four amino acids also play an essential role in BZP block (Fig.
4). Thus, a distinct but overlapping set of amino acid residues in
IIIS6 and IVS6 comprise portions of the DHP and BZP binding sites.
The positions of the determinants of BZP block relative to those of DHP
block are notable for two reasons. First, I1150 and I1460 lie more
toward the extracellular ends of their respective transmembrane
segments than other amino acids interacting with DHPs or PAs (Fig. 4).
This location is consistent with studies using quaternary amine BZPs
indicating that BZPs approach their binding site from the extracellular
side of the membrane (Hering et al., 1993
). We did, however, find that
F1164 and V1165, located toward the intracellular end of IIIS6, also
affect diltiazem block. Intracellular ends of S6 segments are thought
to undergo conformational changes during K+
channel gating (Holmgren et al., 1998
). Therefore, the effects of these
mutant residues may be long-distance allosteric ones secondary to
effects on channel gating. Second, the aliphatic side chains of I1150,
I1153, I1156, and M1160, which are required for BZP block, lie
primarily on one face of the IIIS6 helix. It is possible that BZPs and
DHPs bind simultaneously to different faces of the IIIS6 helix, with
both drugs contacting I1153 and I1156 from opposite sides (Fig. 4).
BZPs and DHPs interact allosterically but not competitively when
binding to the
1C subunit of the L-type
Ca2+ channel. Diltiazem reduces both the
association and dissociation rates of DHP binding, without increasing
the apparent affinity for DHPs (Brauns et al., 1997
). Thus, binding of
diltiazem does not prevent access of DHPs to the determinants within
1C that contribute the bulk of the binding
energy. These previous studies are consistent with a model in which
DHPs and diltiazem bind to distinct faces of the IIIS6 and IVS6
transmembrane segments at distinct but overlapping sites.
Similar but Nonidentical Binding Sites on
1C for
Diltiazem and Phenylalkylamines.
Diltiazem and PAs block L-type
Ca2+ channels in a similar manner. They are less
potent than DHPs and, unlike DHPs, they exhibit striking
frequency-dependent block (Lee and Tsien, 1983
). Previous studies have
implicated transmembrane segments IIIS6 and IVS6 in block of L-type
Ca2+ channels by the high-affinity PA (
)-D888
(Hockerman et al., 1995
, 1997a
; Doring et al., 1996
; Hering et al.,
1997
). Of the seven amino acid residues that may interact directly with
BZPs, only I1153 in segment IIIS6 and Y1463 in segment IVS6 are also important for block by PAs (Fig. 4). I1150, I1156, and M1160 in segment
IIIS6 as well as I1460 and M1464 in segment IVS6 are required for BZP
binding but not PA binding (Fig. 4). Interestingly, F1164 and V1165,
which are not implicated in DHP block, have been proposed as key
determinants in the frequency dependence of both PA and BZP block
(Hering et al., 1997
; Kraus et al., 1998
). Both F1164 and V1165 are
conserved between
1C and
1A, and are therefore present in the
1A/DHPS mutant, where they most likely
contribute substantially to diltiazem action. As noted above, it is
likely that these residues are indirect allosteric effectors of
state-dependent binding of PA and BZPs.
Other amino acid residues in the PA and BZP binding sites in IIIS6 and
IVS6 do not overlap. Amino acids Y1152 in IIIS6 and A1467 and I1470 in
IVS6 are key residues for (
)-D888 block but do not affect block by
diltiazem. Indeed,
1A/DHPS has L-type sensitivity to diltiazem block despite the absence of the L-type specific residue at position 1467. Conversely, I1150, I1156, and M1160
in IIIS6 as well as I1460 and M1464 in IVS6 appear to exclusively affect diltiazem block. Our results differ from those of Hering et al.
(1996)
in which Y1463, A1467, and I1470 were inserted into a P/Q-type
channel and increased diltiazem sensitivity. Also, M1464A had no effect
on diltiazem block, but increased block by the phenylalkylamine
(
)-D600 in the otherwise P/Q-type channel. It is possible that the
different P/Q-type channel subtypes used in these experiments or the
different expression and recording conditions in Xenopus
laevis oocytes (Hering et al., 1996
) mediate the different effects
on drug binding.
Amino Acid Residues Involved in Diltiazem Block of
1C Are Conservatively Substituted in
1A.
A surprising finding of this study is the
relatively small difference between the IC50
values for diltiazem block of wild-type
1C and
1A. Diltiazem has been considered a relatively
specific blocker of L-type Ca2+ channels,
although block of other channel types at higher concentrations has been
noted (Diochot et al., 1995
; Ishibashi et al., 1995
). Our findings
suggest that the selectivity of diltiazem for L-type channels over
P/Q-type channels is less than an order of magnitude. Most of the
determinants of diltiazem block reported here are not conserved between
1C and
1A. How then,
can the P/Q-type channel retain its relatively high degree of
sensitivity to diltiazem?
A clue is provided by our results with the
1A/DHPS mutant, which contains nine L-type
specific amino acids that render it highly sensitive to block by DHP
(Hockerman et al., 1997c
) and diltiazem. The alanine scans of IIIS6 and
IVS6 identified several amino acids that are important for diltiazem
block and are not included in
1A/DHPS (i.e.,
I1150, M1160, I1460; Fig. 4). However, the differences between the
1A and
1C protein
sequences at these positions are very conservative (i.e., V for I at
1150, F for M at 1160, and V for I at 1460; Fig. 4). It is likely that
these hydrophobic amino acids in
1A can
substitute efficiently for the nonidentical but similar hydrophobic
amino acids in
1C, and that the importance of
these positions in diltiazem block comes to light only when the more
drastic substitution of alanine is made. We have previously emphasized
the importance of systematic mutagenesis for identifying functional
properties of amino acids conserved between channel subtypes (Hockerman
et al., 1995
, 1997a
; Peterson et al., 1996
; Peterson et al., 1997
).
This result emphasizes the utility of systematic alanine substitutions
in locating binding determinants where subtype differences are
conservative enough to support the same function.
Further analysis of amino acid differences between the
1A and
1C in
positions that we found to be important for diltiazem block reveals
that three of the remaining four nonconserved residues are relatively
conservative aliphatic-to-hydrophobic aromatic substitutions (i.e.,
I1153 to F, I1156 to F, M1464 to F). One nonconserved position, Y1463,
is replaced by isoleucine in
1A, a substantial
difference in side chain character. In fact, the removal of the
tyrosine hydroxyl in the Y1463F mutation has nearly the same effect as
substitution to alanine in the context of the YAI mutation (Fig. 3).
Thus, at the positions critical for diltiazem block, only one amino
acid is substantially different between
1A and
1C whereas several positions contain
conservative amino acid substitutions. These conservative substitutions
along with conserved residues F1164 and V1165 allow relatively potent
block of
1A by diltiazem.
We thank Lonnie Yeung for excellent technical help with cell
culture and molecular techniques.
This work was supported by National Institutes of Health Grant
PO1-HL44948 and by a research grant-in-aid from the American Heart
Association (W.A.C.) and Scientist Development Grant 9930016N from the
American Heart Association (G.H.H.).
DHP, dihydropyridine;
PA, phenylalkylamine;
BZP, benzothiazepine;
bp, base pairs.